Re:Stop the Slow Lane
by pessimizer on Wednesday May 14, 2014 @11:10AM
(#7744177)
>I'm only seeing vague accusations and little evidence. OTOH, the FCC said clearly and explicitly, and directly to the face of big-ISP that slow lanes are not being proposed and will not under any circumstance be allowed.
It's rhetorical. Slow lanes aren't being proposed, fast lanes are being proposed. It's exactly the same thing, but there's no proposal on the table that explicitly allows ISPs to have the power to leave people who fail to broker a deal with them in a special, non-prioritized "slow lane."
>"Let me be clear. If someone acts to divide the Internet between 'haves' and 'have-nots,'[...]"
This literally means nothing.
Stated more clearly, fast lanes and slow lanes are the same thing. If they both use the same scarce bandwidth resource, then whoever didn't pay for the fast lane by definition ends up in the slower lane. Prioritizing fast lane traffic is the same thing as deprioritizing slow lane traffic, it's a zero sum game if bandwidth is saturated.
When a political figure prefaces with "let me be clear" (why do so many feel a need to use that phrase?) I get the feeling of an attempt to deceive.
"we will use every power at our disposal to stop it". Great Tom. Why don't you do so now, rather than playing wack-a-mole later?
Common Carrier is the answer.
I'm not sure if this is implied by the phrase "common carrier" - but does the presence of a "last lane" imply that the carrier is no longer able to claim "common carrier" status and is therefore liable for the content delivered over their infrastructure? Currently, US ISPs can claim they don't filter based on, eg, obscenity or content that may be illegal in some jurisdiction. If they give up net neutrality, can they be found liable for content?
That's a good point. "Liability" may be an excuse for them to do further packet inspection and traffic shaping.
Sometimes the conspiracist in me wonders if this really isn't about regaining some measure of control over what people can look.
One more point...
When Tom says "we will use every power at our disposal to stop it" he may be speaking technically the truth. But where is the assurance the FCC is planning on retaining the power to do so? Never mind the will. The risk is simply too large.
Re:Stop the Slow Lane
by warmwaffles on Wednesday May 14, 2014 @10:05AM
(#7743749)
Then once the law passes, the FCC chairmen steps down and a new puppet gets implanted.
Re:Stop the Slow Lane
by jessaustin on Wednesday May 14, 2014 @12:05PM
(#7744470)
Perhaps it's a step up when the resigning chair gets a new job that pays much more and requires less work?
Edit: http://www.fcc.gov/document/chairman-tom-wheeler-remarks-nct...