I think the focus on operator overloading is misplaced; in C you might not be able to write "a + b" and have it launch some missiles, but you can write "add(a, b)" and have it launch some missiles, which is just as bad. If anything Scala is more predictable and uniform here - "a + b" is just sugar for "a.+(b)", methods and operators work the same way, and the operator precedence list you have to memorize is much shorter than C's.
Btw what does the operator ~ do in scala?
(It's normal for the same symbol to mean different things in different domains, even in Java. If a and b are BigIntegers, a.add(b) means one thing; if a and b are Wicket components, a.add(b) means something quite different. Wicket remains a respected, well-designed library even though it "overloads" the word "add" in this way)
(Another reply points out that it has the same meaning on numeric types - bitwise negation - as in Java, but I doubt that's what you're asking about)
Compare: (a + (b + c)) + d vs. add(add(a, add(b, c)), d)
One is arithmetic, the other is polish notation.
+ + a + b c d
We can also (with mainstream OO syntax) make add infix and it's still ugly:
a.add(b.add(c)).add(d)
Yuck, really? I find that much less readable than "add(add(a, add(b, c)), d)"
I do have to read it backward and build the stack, but that's basically intuitive at this point.
The ~ operator in scala is the same as in java (if it isn't overloaded)
However, it's pointless to compare methods when we need to be comparing applications. In my experience, I'd say I get about... 100 times reduction in LOC compared to a java application. Not hyperbole, two orders of magnitude LOC reduction compared to java applications.
Now, given that information, does it matter if each particular line takes you three times as long to read? With more type safety to boot?
I feel Scala is beginning to stabilize now. The recent release of 2.11 fixed several annoying issues, notably thread-safe reflection. The community is beginning to build some substantial and usable libraries. There's a still a long road ahead, though.
That being said, I doubt (and fervently hope against!) Scala will ever become Java++. Scala seems to constantly push the boundaries of language design. This is great, as it results in exposure for some lesser-known concepts into the mainstream developer community (e.g. Scala implicits ~= Ruby refinements).
With regards to language stability - the docs will specifically warn you against highly experimental features (e.g. macros), and for many you even need to explicitly import something to enable them.
The type system is very much rock-solid. Scala doesn't force you to use co/contra-variance or higher-kinded types, but they're there should you need to write very theoretically sound or extensible code.
Leaky abstractions, as you mentioned, result in unclear code. On the other hand, well-designed and easily understood abstractions reduce complexity.
Take for example, the atrocious lambda 'hacks' needed before Java 8 - create an anonymous class, then override a method. Compare that with something like words.map { _.size }
Likewise, people don't pay by the character. They pay by the word. They also pay by the concept, so having N different ways to do something simple can be a higher cognitive burden than just 1 way. (hence python vs perl).
Now, I believe that clear code, "well designed" code (despite the fact that its patently obvious that no one agrees on what well designed actually MEANS) are better. Good abstractions.
But these are a function of the programmer from which they come from. The programming language makes a difference but I'm starting to suspect beyond a certain point of feature completeness, you are hitting diminishing returns then negative returns. Yes Java8 has Lambdas, that helps a lot. But would Java9 benefit from implicit parameters? Or from nearly any punctuation being an operator that can be overridden? I argue these 2 features of scala, which people love for their ability to build concise, hard to read, harder to write, DSLs are part of the problem.
Ok enough ranting. My parting shot is I write a 25,000 lines of scala into a production system. We had to rewrite ALL the for loops into while loops. In the end, I'd say Scala was generally helpful but not so much that I'd do it again.
Not so. A quicksort in J is one absolutely lovely counter-example:
quicksort=: (($:@(<#[), (=#[), $:@(>#[)) ({~ ?@#)) ^: (1<#)
It's unarguably shorter than anything you could write in most other languages, but is it more readable?My point is that, while too many characters are bad, too few are bad as well. And that possibly the "just right" verbosity varies from person to person. And also that readability is completely unresearched topic without any established facts we could argue about... Anyway, the key takeaway: we're all wrong on the issue of readability and we don't even know how much wrong.
Some people think that terse code is more readable, not just more writeable.
Definitely you can achieve more with less characters in Scala than Java. Are you paying by the character?
For me, legibility and long term readability is the most dominating factor out of any. This is really subjective, but saving on characters you have to type, only to make the code a lot harder to read seems like penny wise pound foolish to me.
And to pull out an expert who agrees with me, Linus slaps C++ around for many of the same reasons. He noted that it's a lot easier to review patches in C because there is no hidden features (eg: operator overloading) that prevent comprehension.