Re:Where did all the developers go?
by twistedpair on Tuesday May 13, 2014 @12:47PM
(#7739104)
It goes both ways. I've been at a company that had "scrum coaches" that ensured the Agile practices were followed to the letter and fought against the higher managers when they pushed back in waterfall like ways. Agile was quite a success and we shipped a ton of bug free/stable released of our product in 1/6 the time as anyone in the corporate had bid the job at. The process also engaged and empowered developers far more than they had been in the past.
Conversely, at another employer they pasteurized "agile" into their own canned "agile-fall" methodology that had many antipodal theoretical conflicts, resulting in just 4 week single iteration waterfall sprints. The results of said agile-fall were very lackluster as no one was empowered, and there no greater clarity into process for dev's.
As such, there is certainly a right and wrong way to do agile. I'd say too many companies fear it because it let's the patients run the asylum (dev's) and reveals that you really don't need so many PHB's.
Really sad that at the end of the day "Agile" meant more admin work and meetings and no noticeable improvements (to me). Of course management saw "improvements" but the "scrum masters" would just tweak numbers to make it look like we met deadlines or completed enough story points. It was really sickening to watch everyone pat everyone else on the back for doing a good job when I knew at least 1/3rd of the scrum teams didn't get close to what they were supposed to accomplish.