Re:Deep Intellect: Inside the mind of the octopus
by jessaustin on Monday May 12, 2014 @12:45PM
(#7733818)
Humans were sentient long before they knew how to write...
You're so right, and it seems one sees this error constantly in discussions like this. Human beings like us have been around for 200,000 years, and only within the last 10,000 have even some of us written anything down. Yet we assume that civilization, with farming and government and writing, is somehow the default for this species.
Re:Deep Intellect: Inside the mind of the octopus
by vadman on Monday May 12, 2014 @08:42PM
(#7736130)
Dogs do not pass the mirror test, which, hypothetically, indicates they have no concept of "self" - thus they cannot think about themselves.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirror_test - there is a discussion about dogs specifically, noting that vision is not their primary sense, so the mirror test may have less value.
Obviously dogs won't write about their brains being sentient, but how do you know that they don't think about themselves?
Humans were sentient long before they knew how to write, or which part of the body is responsible for their thoughts. What makes us think we're so special?
I am quite sure dogs can predict future behaviour of simple systems and act on these systems to achieve their goals. Problem solving in dogs is widely documented and I think it suffices to assume at least some sentience.