The bar is set high, though; the dream is about 1GB/s, RDRAND achieves 500-700MB/s.
>The bar is set high, though; the dream is about 1GB/s, RDRAND achieves 500-700MB/s.
Why are PRNGs not good enough? A hardware implementation of algorithms in the SHA series can achieve multiple GB/s of throughput. With a good seed, wouldn't the output of a simple counter-based or iterative hash-based PRNG be sufficiently random for simulations?
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6060636
Obviously computers are much faster now than they were in 1997; and as you say we only need a small amount for entropy.
The devices you point to use the semiconductor avalanche effect (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avalanche_breakdown) which is a thermal effect.
But in the end it doesn't matter, any unpredictable, non manipulable source of randomness is fine. Other sources of noise in electrical circuits (apart from quantum noise origins) are interference (like the 60Hz hum, radio interference, and even background radiation)
The traditional quantum optics setup does, however. The basic design is also a lot simpler: you've got your source of photons, your half-silvered mirror, a bunch of detectors and you're ready to go.
Here are some devices from ID Quantique that use quantum optics:
http://www.idquantique.com/component/content/article.html?id...
I'm interested in what makes you think that. If you could predict the precise course of electrons through a reverse biased pn junction, I would have thought that would be a breakthrough in quantum mechanics worthy of the Nobel Prize in physics.
I fully understand why algorithmic pseudo-random numbers can be said to be not 'true' random numbers -- if you know the algorithm that produces the numbers, and you know enough of the numbers output by any particular 'round' of random-number-generation production, you can in principle figure out how the algorithm was seeded -- or narrow it down to a few possible seeds -- and predict with greater accuracy its future outputs. (I'd like to know if I've got that wrong).
But in this case, that doesn't seem to be a concern. What could make someone think it's an 'un-true' RNG? What, to such a person, would a 'true' RNG look like? Is thermal noise an 'un-true' RNG? Why?
I post a link elsewhere in the thread with some description. RFC4046 has some more information.
So, while the hole-electron moving[1] through the pn junction is quantum there's a bunch of other stuff that can be sent to the output stream and that poor software implementations include as random.
[1] apologies to physicists for inaccurate terminology. I never really know how to describe what hPpens with holes and electrons in semi conductors.
It's just that the optical system is simpler, and still predicts true randomness. So if I were forced to e.g. build a business based on true random numbers, I'd probably go for the simpler system.
The problem of generating quantum random numbers is same as with optical device: removing all other sources of noise.
My understanding is it's pretty straightforward to do so - here's a nice little device available on tindie:
https://www.tindie.com/products/ubldit/truerng-hardware-rand...
And here is the physical process it's based on from a (5 year old) paper.
http://cockrum.net/Implementation_of_ECC_on_an_8-bit_microco...
And, not to be pedantic, but you really only need a small amount of entropy to seed your PRNG - for all practical purposes, the rest of the random bits can be computationally generated.