Anyway, I never said the web as an app platform can't be done. I'm asking if it is a good idea, and if we are fully considering the tradeoffs involved (i.e. a bit of 'engineering'). I don't find 'because we can' a great reason when it comes to things that affect the lives of most computer using people. A higher level of responsibility is involved in these situations than somebodies experimental spare time github repos.
I could sit here and think of a dozen feasible ways to get water from ground level to the first floor of my house. It wouldn't be 'toxic to progress' to point out that there are better ways than an archimedes screw powered by a horse in the garden. Thinking about better ways to do things rather than just blundering forwards with the first idea that comes to mind is exactly how progress is made.
As for the hose analogy, municipal water distribution systems are still powered by gravity. Which is quite a bit older than the Archimedes screw. A good illustration that usually something simple is all you need.
Computers were designed to do math, not word processing or gaming or mapping of massive datasets into comprehensible reports. Attitudes like this are toxic to progress, in my opinion, and far too common.