News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First life with 'alien' DNA by dekhn on Thursday May 08, 2014 @02:07PM (#7716696)
Somewhere in La Jolla, Peter Schultz is asking why he's not getting credit for having done this... years ago.
Re:First life with 'alien' DNA by cjensen on Thursday May 08, 2014 @02:55PM (#7716969)
Assuming Wikipedia describes Schultz's work correctly, this is a different achievement.

DNA is essentially an instruction set. Each instruction is three base-four digits (a sequence of three base pairs). A single instruction is either STOP, START, and for every amino acid there is one or more ADD AMINO ACID TO SEQUENCE instruction.

Schultz altered the interpretation of some of the ADD AMINO instructions so that a different, non-natural amino acid is added.

This new creation alters the mechanism by changing from a base-four instruction set to a base-eight instruction set. As a side benefit, bacteria based on this new mechanism cannot reproduce in the wild.

Re:First life with 'alien' DNA by dekhn on Thursday May 08, 2014 @03:07PM (#7717035)
The interesting part of schultz's work is the use of modified tRNA adapters. Personally, I think this is a far more tractable approach.
Re:First life with 'alien' DNA by epistasis on Thursday May 08, 2014 @02:52PM (#7716947)
EDIT: I had also completely misremembered this, thanks to cjensen for the correction. On a similar note, their next efforts are to use these new bases in the genetic code. While it's very interesting and could have some great uses for restricting the spread of modified organisms, an expanded amino acid repertoire is a much more useful achievement.

The weird thing is that it's another lab in La Jolla that published this, so they must have known about Schultz's work. What's new about this work vs. Schultz's work, and if he's in the same institution, why didn't they work with him on this? I saw Schultz talk several years ago, and was really impressed; what is the improvement that justifies the claims of a huge milestone?

Science reporting is completely fucked up.

Re:First life with 'alien' DNA by ucarion on Thursday May 08, 2014 @03:00PM (#7716992)
I think the main breakthrough here is that these nucleotides are not only unnatural but that the host can actually duplicate them; the E coli in this experiment passed the new nucleotides to 24 child cells.
Re:First life with 'alien' DNA by fixermark on Thursday May 08, 2014 @03:37PM (#7717200)
And also, "When the supply of foreign nucleotides ran out, the bacteria replaced the foreign bases with natural ones."

This could have interesting implications in the theory of the origin of life; with DNA/carbon-based life shown to be adaptable to slightly different forms of the chemicals it needs in the deepest levels of genetic encoding, the set of initial conditions that could give rise to the life we see today grows.

Re:First life with 'alien' DNA by ronaldx on Thursday May 08, 2014 @07:21PM (#7718335)
Schultz's work (as I've understood) modified tRNA to alter the genetic code[0] which converts nucleobases into amino acids. This allows for a different code compared to the one found in nature.

This work, on the other hand, adds 2 new nucleobases to the existing 4 bases.

That's not the same. IMHO it's a very different and novel work: in principle the genetic code can now accept an alphabet of up to 216 amino acids, compared to 64 previously (with nature essentially using 20 of those; this assumes three-nucleotide codons).

It's true that Schultz's work, at a higher level, is necessary for this to be of any practical use. But this work has significant additional benefit on its own: for example, I believe you could immediately construct a genetic code that used the additional redundancy to be far more stable against mutation.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_code

Re:First life with 'alien' DNA by aheilbut on Thursday May 08, 2014 @08:17PM (#7718575)
Somewhere in La Jolla, Peter Schultz is probably not all that worried about it.