Re:NASA, CNES Warn SpaceX of Challenges in Flying Reusable F...
by marvin on Wednesday May 07, 2014 @01:45PM
(#7711614)
There's another point here: The Falcon 9 rockets are much simpler than the Space Shuttle. It doesn't make sense to compare the most ridiculous hybrid of sailplane and rocket that's ever been created by a committée of politicians with a rocket design that's at its core an incremental development over tried-and-true rocket designs.
There is so much more margin of error with the Falcon 9, the industry veterans have no idea what they are talking about. Their experiences are built on a generation of excessive complexity.
Re:NASA, CNES Warn SpaceX of Challenges in Flying Reusable F...
by mikeash on Wednesday May 07, 2014 @02:51PM
(#7711989)
I must object to your use of the word "sailplane". The Shuttle was a glider. A sailplane is a glider that can soar by climbing in rising air.
Anyway, you are right. The amazing thing about Falcon 9R is just how little was added to the standard Falcon 9. Slap some legs on it and give it some fancy software and call it a day, pretty much. It's a completely different world from custom-designing a reusable spaceplane from scratch.
Re:NASA, CNES Warn SpaceX of Challenges in Flying Reusable F...
by marvin on Wednesday May 07, 2014 @05:13PM
(#7712689)
Point taken on the semantics I suppose, but I do actually have a glider pilot's license and have been flying gliders (the soaring kind) in mountainous terrain for six years. Never bothered with the distinction since most pilots over here call their aircraft gliders, but I suppose there is a textbook definition somewhere that disagrees.
Re:NASA, CNES Warn SpaceX of Challenges in Flying Reusable F...
by mikeash on Wednesday May 07, 2014 @10:17PM
(#7713637)
Well, they are gliders. All sailplanes are gliders, but not all gliders are sailplanes.
I don't know that too many people make that distinction, but it does seem to be the accepted definition of "sailplane". There's nothing wrong with calling, say, an ASW-20 a glider, but calling the Shuttle a sailplane isn't quite right.
If you're doing six launches a year, then building six new rockets a year is not really much more expensive than building one rocket once and refurbishing it for a new launch six times a year. Especially when you complicate the design to an extreme degree to achieve reusability, thus causing that one rocket to cost a ton of money to build and a ton of money to refurbish.
Where he gets it wrong, I think, is that Falcon 9R is not a pure reusable system. It's an expendable system that's been lightly modified for reusability. This is important because it means that the rocket is still cheap to build and cheap to refurbish.
Look at the Shuttle program: they built four orbiters initially, then a fifth as a replacement after one was destroyed, and that's it. They operated these things for decades.
Compare with the Falcon 9R program: they built, launched, and deliberately threw away one already. They'll do this several more times. The vehicles are cheap enough that they can intentionally lose hardware as part of the test program. The vehicles are capable enough that they can get paid to test them by still using them to launch payloads into orbit while doing it.
The Shuttle had to fly dozens of times a year just to break even compared to the cost of building new expendable rockets. They could never come anywhere close to that. This is the sort of thing that M. Bonnal is referring to, and it makes sense in that context. The difference is that Falcon 9R costs little more than a regular Falcon 9 to build, and on the second launch it will already be past breakeven and saving money. Perhaps it can be reused 40 times, but unlike the Shuttle, it doesn't need to be reused 40 times to justify an extremely high initial cost and extremely high ongoing overhead.