It depends on why you're writing the song I guess. If you're writing a pop song you want to get to the top of the charts following that formula is probably essentially (although it obviously doesn't guarantee success). Just listen to some of the top pop songs - they clearly have a formula. The problem is that when everything follows the formula you can't listen to much of it because it gets boring.
I'd say if you're writing a song you want to last, something that will potentially go down as a classic, forget about formulas a write what you think sounds good.
This is why I can't stand pop music, and can't understand why it's so .... popular. I've already heard the C-major scale in 4/4 time, layered with false emotion by a 20 year old who's seen it all.
That doesn't mean that there doesn't occasionally come along a good song or two. It's still perfectly possible to write a 4/4 song in C and have it be interesting/fun/good to listen to. Unfortunately you'll have to wade through a whole load of crap in the pop charts before you find it ;)
I think the graphs would be more interesting if they weighted the values according to e.g. the number of playlists a skipping user listens to regularly (or not, if they are a listener who seeks out new combinations/playlists).
“It’s not enough to have one hook anymore,” Jay Brown, the president of Roc Nation, and Dean’s manager, told me recently. “You’ve got to have a hook in the intro, a hook in the pre-chorus, a hook in the chorus, and a hook in the bridge.” The reason, he explained, is that “people on average give a song seven seconds on the radio before they change the channel, and you got to hook them.”
http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2012/03/26/120326fa_fact_...