Re:Science and the Demise of Philosophy
by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday August 18, 2009 @06:08AM
(#770130)
what is _really_ true IS what makes the best predictions. Otherwise in what sense is it true? Qualia has no effect demonstrable to an inside observer because you have no other data points to compare to. You have only one data point: your own consciousness.
>what is _really_ true IS what makes the best predictions. Otherwise in what sense is it true?
That is the anti-realist position, but it could be true in the sense that it corresponds to the actual nature of reality, if you are a realist.
> You have only one data point: your own consciousness.
Yep, and that is the data point that physicalism doesn't seem to be able to account for.
Re:Science and the Demise of Philosophy
by nazgulnarsil on Wednesday August 19, 2009 @12:44AM
(#772082)
you're covering it up with the term "actual" what does that mean?
your second assertion doesn't make any sense either. "account" would imply that pzombies would be different from "normal" normal people I guess?
Certainly, a _scientific theory_ is judged based on its predictive power. This is why I mentioned my opinion, earlier, that science is "the art of useful fiction." The goal isn't to achieve truth but to predict.
Philosophy, on the other hand, is concerned with what is _really_ true, not predictions.
Certainly, the experience of qualia has no effect demonstrable to an outside observer. That doesn't make it any more or less real. I experience, therefore it must exist. I merely can't prove it to you. The great thing is that you can prove it to yourself. All you have to do is pause for a moment and rationally examine what you feel.
If your interested in an attempt to explain it from a materialist perspective, you may wish to look at Roger Penrose _The Emperor's New Mind_. He argues that consciousness is intricately tied to QM. Or at least I think he does... It's difficult reading and I haven't read the whole thing yet!
It's on Google Books, here: http://books.google.ca/books?id=oI0grArWHUMC&dq=The+Empe...
The first chapter provides an excellent explanation of qualia.