News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by hadoukenio on Sunday May 04, 2014 @07:56AM (#7693978)
It's getting more and more common these days that whenever I talk to people about travel, the US is completely off their list. The TSA, NSA, NYPD, Bloods and Crips, the reasons go on.

It used to be that Disney Land was one of the reasons to go to America. More and more people I speak to who would have gone now say "meh" to the idea.

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by tokenadult on Sunday May 04, 2014 @08:28AM (#7694044)
It's getting more and more common these days that whenever I talk to people about travel, the US is completely off their list.

As people in the United States wake up on a Sunday morning in their time zones, I guess it falls on me to say that this all depends on whom you talk to. I know lots of people who desire to visit the United States. The United States is still second only to France as the country most visited by tourists from other countries.[1] That's remarkable to me because France has land borders with several other countries, all countries with large populations, while the United States mostly has to be reached by transoceanic air travel.

The original post says, "I have heard that if I have been to some countries I might be refused to enter the US." What it does not say is, "I have checked the United States laws and have checked actual practice of what happens at the United States border, to see how that compares with border control in other countries." And then there are a couple of anecdotes in the few responses. This is basically not a high-quality submission for Hacker News, as it doesn't promote the thoughtful, informed discussion that should characterize our community here.

The typical set of Hacker News comments about the United States from people who have never been to the United States seems to mingle two points of view. On the one hand, the United States is criticized as an undesirable place that no one would want to live in or even visit, given a choice. On the other hand, the United States is criticized as an inhospitable place that doesn't give free, unrestricted entry to anyone who wants to work or visit or settle in the United States. (Criticisms of United States immigration policy on Hacker News mostly take the form of saying that the United States should let in more immigrants like, um, the people who participate on Hacker News.) A fable attributed to the Greek author Aesop[2] may explain how these seemingly contrary opinions of the United States can exist in the mind of the same person.

[1] http://www.smh.com.au/travel/travel-news/the-worlds-most-pop...

http://time.com/10296/most-popular-countries-to-visit-map/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Tourism_rankings

(Some sources disagree on the exact ranking, but every source I checked puts France first and puts the United States in the top five.)

[2] http://www.bartleby.com/17/1/31.html

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by avar on Sunday May 04, 2014 @09:15AM (#7694163)

    > That's remarkable to me because France has land borders with
    > several other countries, all countries with large populations,
    > while the United States mostly has to be reached by transoceanic
    > air travel.
No, it mostly doesn't have to be reached by transoceanic air travel. According to some quick searching[1] around more than half of the tourists coming into the US are from Canada and Mexico.

It certainly has more of an international mix than France[2] due to France's proximity to to other countries though.

1. http://geography.about.com/b/2012/05/02/country-of-origin-of... 2. http://www.dgcis.gouv.fr/files/files/directions_services/etu...

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by rlongstaff on Sunday May 04, 2014 @09:22AM (#7694181)
I have visited the USA a dozen or so times over the past decade and, as well as having a great number of friends there, I've found the people really friendly and welcoming.

The only exception to this are US immigration officials who I dread dealing with everytime I arrive. All my paperwork is in order and I've never visited any of those 'dodgy' countries but they are just so unfriendly and standoffish that it spoils my arrival. I get the impression they assume every arriving person has no right to enter and should be treated almost like a criminal.

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by orting on Sunday May 04, 2014 @10:02AM (#7694323)
I remember visiting family in the states in 2008, we had our 9 month old child with us. Arriving in the US we got fast-tracked through security, allowed to bring formula for the baby with us and was generally treated very politely. In London we were asked to open all containers with baby food and taste it.

There are countless anecdotes illustrating how immigration rules and officers are ridiculous and racist, but not all of them are about USA. In many respects immigrants are treated worse in Europe that in the states.

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by phantom784 on Sunday May 04, 2014 @12:40PM (#7694840)
I believe the official policy is to assume everyone is planning to remain illegally and it's up to you to prove otherwise (e.g. by showing ties to your home country)
Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by pasbesoin on Sunday May 04, 2014 @09:32AM (#7694217)
I think that one of the problems is that the parameters used in analyzing e.g. visa requests, among other things, are not clearly laid out.

To some extent, we are reduced to anecdote, because an opaque and sometimes seemingly capricious (if not malicious) system -- or set of sometimes cooperating, sometimes competing systems -- leaves us no choice.

There also appears to be no effective and consistent gradation in risk management. No ability to elicit further investigation and potential resolution of open questions -- whether they are legitimate or the result of an inept initial evaluation.

A prime example of this, not with respect to visas but with respect to ongoing travel, with plans already made and tickets already purchased, is the "no-fly list" and other apparent, more obscure and hidden lists and qualifications having similar effects upon travel.

Are you on it? We can't tell you. Why are you on it? We can't tell you. I (general "I") have a mountain of evidence I can present demonstrating that I'm not a threat. There's no effective appeal process (never mind any "ostensible" appeal process; much reporting has demonstrated such to apparently be entirely non-functional). I'm willing to submit to search to demonstrate that I am not nor am carrying any immediate threat. Not an option.

That and why you are on the list is a secret. Options to mitigate a perceived risk and allow travel are not an option.

Hardly hallmarks of an "open" society.

I mention the "no-fly list" also in good part because it applies also to U.S. citizens. Such cases are not a matter of a foreign national soliciting the U.S. for a... "privilege". They reflect a government opaquely and apparently extra-judicially limiting free association (via travel).

The U.S. is still the envy of much of the world, and not without some good reasons. And the majority of trips both by foreign nationals and by U.S. citizens take place without undo circumstance. But the trend in travel restrictions worries me, for one. And, as an ostensibly self-governing citizenry, how are we to effectively govern as such policies increasingly cut us off from controversial parts of the world we might do well to actually pay more attention to? Such governance includes foreign policy. Also, foreign examples can serve as useful lessons in guiding our own domestic policy -- if such examples are though of as "bad", then as examples of things to learn from and hopefully avoid.

token, I know you as an open-minded, insightful, and "fair" participant, here, and I don't mean my response to come across as overly "argumentative" or upset. Rather, I take your point, but present my own not so much as a counter-point but as an adjunct that I think also needs to be considered, and so I'm mentioning it in this response.

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by tokenadult on Sunday May 04, 2014 @09:47AM (#7694264)
I take your point, but present my own not so much as a counter-point but as an adjunct that I think also needs to be considered, and so I'm mentioning it in this response.

I appreciate that. (Upvoted, of course.) Thank you. I've noticed before that you devote effort to building up a thoughtful community here.

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by VexXtreme on Sunday May 04, 2014 @09:04AM (#7694124)
No offense but the tone of your post screams 'butthurt'. Leave your national pride and various statistics-based pissing contests out of this (and the sour grapes argument is completely emotion-based and irrelevant). There are many legitimate reasons for non-Americans to avoid the US these days and unpleasant immigration procedures are just one of them. I am for one simply afraid of going there, not knowing what kind of horrible treatment I can expect at the border if I rub some immigration officer the wrong way, and this is coming from a white European. Many of my friends feel the same way. I can only imagine what a Middle Eastern-looking person with a few stamps from 'undesirable' countries in their passport must feel like.
Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by tokenadult on Sunday May 04, 2014 @09:12AM (#7694151)
I have lived outside the United States (in a non-Western, non-English-speaking country) for a large percentage of my adult life, so I am very open to the perspective of people from other countries. And as I have done my own crossing of international borders, I see that each country sets its own rules about who crosses with what kind of paperwork. Unrestricted discretion of border control officers is the general rule of international law, alas, despite a period of history (before when any of us were born) when it was routine for most people to be allowed to travel freely to most civilized countries.

I don't imagine what people feel like when I can observe what people feel like. What I observe is that a lot more people on Hacker News and elsewhere desire to visit the United States and to settle in the United States[1] than decide never to go to the United States at all. That's a fact of the world that I have to deal with without emotion or name-calling but just by thinking about what policy implications that fact has.

[1] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/dec/14/united-states-i...

http://www.pewresearch.org/daily-number/u-s-is-top-destinati...

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by JoeAltmaier on Sunday May 04, 2014 @09:07AM (#7694136)
Yeah politics suck. I remember when my older brother travelled to India to visit the in-laws. Unfortunately for him some American customs folk had turned away an Indian diplomat the previous day. So it was 'turn Americans away day' and he was the unfortunate pawn. Too a couple of days before it blew over.
Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by kylemaxwell on Sunday May 04, 2014 @09:13AM (#7694153)
"No offense but" is code for "I am about to say something offensive." And are you really suggesting that statistics - facts - are irrelevant?
Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by antocv on Sunday May 04, 2014 @08:20AM (#7694029)
A friend of mine said he would never visit Saudi Arabia because he could get jailed or killed for no reason or no fair trial. I told him thats my reason for not visiting USA, Bradley Manning among a list of many and Guantanamo.
Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by jpatokal on Sunday May 04, 2014 @08:30AM (#7694047)
Also, you would not be "jailed or killed for no reason" in Saudi Arabia -- it's just that some of the reasons you would be jailed are a bit unusual (adultery, alcohol, proselytizing).

https://en.wikivoyage.org/wiki/Saudi_Arabia#Respect

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by vacri on Sunday May 04, 2014 @09:59AM (#7694309)
I once worked with an Eritrean whose family came to Australia by way of Canada after moving to Saudi. They moved away from Saudi because my colleague's father noted that there are no protections for black people under Saudi law - if something went wrong, they were utterly screwed. They could be targeted by criminals and the law wouldn't care a jot. Saudi laws should not be characterised as "just a little stricter and odder than we're used to".

http://www.frontpagemag.com/2014/dgreenfield/saudi-arabia-th...

Saudi also practises that modern form of slavery where slaves aren't property now, they're merely foreign labourers who have had their identity documents removed so they can't escape and their promised wages withheld. http://www.al-bab.com/blog/2013/december/saudi-arabia-defend...

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by PythonicAlpha on Sunday May 04, 2014 @09:06AM (#7694134)
Or for women: Having been raped ....

(I don't find the link now, but there was a news about a European woman, that was raped and when she was going to the police, she was arrested for adultery and threatened with jail (I think) or else she should marry the rapist. I am not sure, if it was Saudi Arabia or a neighboring country, but such a thing just makes me ill!)

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by kps on Sunday May 04, 2014 @09:32AM (#7694222)
You're probably thinking of Marte Dalelv, a Norwegian woman on a business trip in Dubai†. Or possibly Alicia Gali, the Australian woman raped and then jailed 8 months in Fujairah UAE‡.

†http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prosecution_of_Marte_Dalelv ‡http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alicia_Gali

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by chestnut-tree on Sunday May 04, 2014 @09:00AM (#7694113)
The US remains a very popular tourist destination and I'm guessing that many European countries will also look suspiciously at your passport if you've recently travelled to countries embroiled in conflict such as Syria, Iraq or Afghanistan.

I'd like to visit the US, but I don't like the idea of having my fingerprints taken and stored for 75 years by US authorities. Of course, it's completely within the right of US authorities to decide the rules for entry into their country and I suspect it deters a very small number of people. Fingerprints are also taken by EU countries that issue biometric passports: http://euobserver.com/news/121816

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by tzs on Sunday May 04, 2014 @08:30AM (#7694050)
Bloods and Crips? How are the Bloods and Crips a reason to avoid travel to the US?
Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by fennecfoxen on Sunday May 04, 2014 @08:49AM (#7694080)
Ignorance.

Ignorance of how they work and how unlikely they are to affect your life. (I'm sure many Americans are similarly ignorant about some "dangerous" group in another geographic location which is in fact dangerous but unlikely to be encountered.)

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by yummyfajitas on Sunday May 04, 2014 @09:15AM (#7694164)
People back in the US worry about me getting robbed/murdered here in India. Apparently a country full of poor folks must be dangerous like Newark, NJ.

(India is dangerous, but not for men, and not because of poverty.)

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by hadoukenio on Sunday May 04, 2014 @05:11PM (#7695821)
I was mainly talking about gang violence and the US' extremely high shooting rate. It was only last year that an Australian was shot while he was jogging by a group of 15 year old boys for no reason except that they were bored:

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-02-05/teenages-accused-in-de...

Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by fennecfoxen on Monday May 05, 2014 @08:27PM (#7702184)
Maybe, but look at risk in a little more detached of a manner: essentially no one is going to come to the US and get shot. They're going to come to the US and die in a car crash.
Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by mindslight on Sunday May 04, 2014 @09:21AM (#7694178)
I figured OP just got carried away listing lawless gangs of thugs. Or it could have been a reference to republicans and democrats - fighting each other for business turf, and hurting everyone else in the process.
Re:Countries you shouldn't visit if you want to travel to th... by tptacek on Sunday May 04, 2014 @11:01PM (#7696790)
That is perhaps the lamest attempt at segueing a thread to partisan politics that I've ever read here. But it's true, I'm always warning my foreign visitors to stay out of the crossfire of warring Democrats and Republicans; they can be lethal.