News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by tambourine_man on Saturday May 03, 2014 @05:38PM (#7692430)
I've been hearing about the end of Moore's Law ever since I was a kid. I remember smart people citing wave lengths and economics convincing me that there as no way we'd go beyond 300nm. Oh yes, and that would mean the end of x86 as well (since intel wouldn't have the process advantage to compensate for the less efficient CISC).

Well, maybe they are right this time, who knows, but I'm way more skeptical.

Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by bsder on Saturday May 03, 2014 @05:48PM (#7692457)
Moore's Law broke a while ago. Note the past tense.

nVidia couldn't get their economics at 28nm. RAM cells are now more expensive in 20nm than 28nm. There are lots of other examples.

Remember: the strong form of Moore's law was that transistors get cheaper ever 12-18 months. The original formulation of Moore's law was always about economics, not technology.

The problem is: nobody knows what to do.

You now need clever circuit design and humans who can squeeze another 15-20% out of existing technologies. Unfortunately, all the humans who knew how to do custom VLSI design are dead, retired, or doing something else since custom VLSI was fool's errand for so long (see DEC, IBM, Silicon Graphics, etc.).

Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by williadc on Saturday May 03, 2014 @06:18PM (#7692531)
> You now need clever circuit design and humans who can squeeze another 15-20% out of existing technologies. Unfortunately, all the humans who knew how to do custom VLSI design are dead, retired, or doing something else since custom VLSI was fool's errand for so long (see DEC, IBM, Silicon Graphics, etc.).

Broadwell is a custom-designed part, and it's scaled extremely well from 22nm to 14nm. There have been yield issues going to 14nm, but the biggest hurdles have been solved, with a lot of help from the design team. I guess Intel must have hired all the people you think are dead or retired.

Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by sliverstorm on Saturday May 03, 2014 @09:14PM (#7692965)
It really helps to specify what you mean by custom. There is hand-built vs. tool-built, there is full-custom vs. semi-custom, etc...

I for one doubt Broadwell is hand-built, hand-routed, full-custom. Which is what your parent was probably talking about, as they mention DEC.

Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by sliverstorm on Saturday May 03, 2014 @09:19PM (#7692982)
Unfortunately, all the humans who knew how to do custom VLSI design are dead, retired, or doing something else

Well, sort of. The ol' DEC guys are still out there, many at semiconductor companies.

Anyway, design is not the biggest lever right now, and it stabilizes last. When architecture & process slow down, design will probably see increased focus as you finally have more time for squeezing out 20% extra speed- and without everything being tossed the next go-round.

Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by hga on Saturday May 03, 2014 @07:35PM (#7692731)
I'm not sure you can extrapolate that from one company's use of one foundry's process nodes. Intel at least seems to be doing well with their 22 nm process node.
Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by marcosdumay on Saturday May 03, 2014 @11:32PM (#7693202)
Yep, they seem to be doing well, but they are almost an entire doubling time later if you compare the two previous doublings with to Moore's law.
Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by hga on Sunday May 04, 2014 @10:06AM (#7694336)
This might in part be explained by their moving to nonplanar FinFET transistors. And in practice their geometry doesn't quite match the idealized drawings: http://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1261761
Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by hershel on Sunday May 04, 2014 @01:01AM (#7693309)
Who knows. How can anybody tell if 28nm if more cost effective than 28 nm when it isn't sold in the market as a fab ?
Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by darkmighty on Saturday May 03, 2014 @06:03PM (#7692491)
The difference this time is we're already there. Sure, the only physical limit to computing I'm willing to give with current research is Bremmermann's limit [1], but it doesn't mean we'll ever reach it.

Our brain is awesome with a merely few 10's of billions of elements. We sure can do better than what we have with cpus with a few billions of transistors -- the problem must be we don't have a clue of what to do with them. A hint to that is even the most powerful supercomputers with 100's of trillions of transistors still can't do better than our brain in some tasks.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bremermann%27s_limit

Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by simple_logic on Saturday May 03, 2014 @08:22PM (#7692845)
A single transistor can't do the job of a neuron and 500 synapses.
Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by PeterisP on Saturday May 03, 2014 @09:35PM (#7693014)
A couple transistors may be enough to do the job of a synapse - and it would do that "job" many orders of magnitude faster.

A modern CPU has some 100000 times less transistors than we have synapses, but it's effective frequency is at at least 1000000 faster than synapse firing rates. So on "volume" ratio our CPUs are already more powerful than our brains, we just don't know how to wire those transistors properly.

It may well be that the power of such a neural network is nonlinear to its size, and a tenfold smaller/tenfold faster network is much weaker. But we do already have supercomputers that have a similar number of transistors than our brains have synapses, while still having the millionfold speed advantage.

Our limit is in our [lack of] ability to build brains. If we knew how, then our current silicon tech would be enough to run ubiquitous stronger-than-human AIs - but we don't; and "bruteforcing" a brain emulation without a better understanding is so inefficient that it requires currently unfeasible resources.

Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by stcredzero on Saturday May 03, 2014 @09:26PM (#7692997)
Synapses turned out to be more complicated than we thought. Single cell organisms did all of their sensing and data processing through their membranes. Guess what synapses evolved from?
Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by tedsanders on Saturday May 03, 2014 @05:54PM (#7692473)
You're right that people cried wolf before and were wrong. However, that doesn't mean they're wrong this time too. There are many good reasons to think that Moore's Law is ending. Next-gen lithography is just getting too expensive for scaling to be economically feasible, let alone technically feasible.
Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by XorNot on Saturday May 03, 2014 @07:16PM (#7692679)
This is an economically invalid argument without more detail. The only way a lithography process can be too expensive is if it has an extremely skewed lag time (i.e. 6 months prep per line, with low throughput) or if the consumables of the process are very expensive or very wasted.

None of the possible future processes has any of these constraints (with the exception of perhaps E-beam lithography, but it's not a hard constraint).

If you can build a continuous fabrication line with a process, then no matter how much it costs, the capital-investment eventually diminishes to a tiny fraction of the cost of each chip, compared to consumables.

Current lithography processes were "too expensive" previously. But they've been running continuously since they were built, and so are again a tiny fraction of the cost of an actual processor today.

Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by tedsanders on Sunday May 04, 2014 @12:07AM (#7693251)
Another factor to consider is discounting. Even if a technology has zero marginal cost, it's not necessarily profitable when you take opportunity cost and discounting into account.
Re:End of Moore's Law: It's not just about physics by higherpurpose on Saturday May 03, 2014 @06:35PM (#7692585)
Moore's Law is already mostly dead (for Intel). Look how little they add in performance with each new generation. At best, they get some significant gains for ultra-specific instructions by adding accelerators to their chips (say for computational photography or whatever), but that's something everyone else can do, too, and at that point we're not talking about CPU performance anyway.