Re:Common LibreSSL porting mistakes
by lplplplplp on Friday May 02, 2014 @04:43AM
(#7684651)
Most is invalid in principle, perhaps not in practice (stupid as that is):
1. Ye shall use C11 memset_s().
2. Ye shall (as you note) use a reallocarray() with OpenBSD-like (ANSI C) wrap checking.
3. Ye shall use /dev/urandom on Linux (I know you guys love him, see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7361868 by tptacek)
4. Also, timingsafe_bcmp() is 3 lines of ANSI C99 code (minus variable and function declarations), include it with the code (as you note).
If you look at the portable versions of their products they tend to ship a chunk of the OpenBSD library implementation with them to give consistency guarantees.
Perhaps we need a consistent OpenBSD platform abstraction layer that gives solid guarantees?