News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yahoo ends support of “Do Not Track” by qwerty_asdf on Thursday May 01, 2014 @09:26PM (#7683679)
But has there ever been a precise specification of what it means to "track" a user? Does "track" have any finite meaning, or is it just an open-ended plea from the user for everyone to pretend that certain events never happened?

To speak of "tracking" one might mean:

  A. Thou shalt not cookie a user.
  
  B. Thou shalt not record plain text log files on a 
     server-side file system, regarding the nature of these 
     requests. Thou shalt not persist discrete information 
     to a relational database, with respect to these 
     particular HTTP requests.

  C. Thou shalt not inspect which IP address HTTP POST 
     requests originate from, and treat them differently, if 
     a user proclaims "no tracksies". GET requests will be 
     treated as read-only requests for static resources. If 
     the static resources change, I wish to play no part in 
     such events.

  D. Thou shalt neither inspect ANY HTTP requests (PUT, 
     DELETE, POST or GET), nor serve individualized 
     resources, regardless of any particular attributes 
     present in the request. Thou shalt only keep the 
     specific data I tell you to keep, and destroy 
     everything else related to my requests. At a later 
     point in time, I reserve the right to become 
     irrationally angry about your having kept the *some* of
     the data I told you to keep, because, technically 
     speaking, the DO-NOT-TRACK header is all encompassing, 
     and supercedes all other instructions. I also reserve 
     the right to get angry if *your* system does not 
     perform according to *my* expectations, whatever those 
     expectations may be, at any particular time.

  E. Thou shalt not provide me with any uniquely 
     identifiable information. I do not wish to receive 
     information which has not already been provided to 
     anyone else. Please do not transmit unique information 
     to me over the wire or over the air. Doing so will 
     change the state of my system in a unique way, which 
     I'll eventually have to answer to. If I receive non-
     standard resources and information from you, my service 
     provider and local authorities, may use this against 
     me, and derive other information from these details. I 
     may be penalized for knowing or having things other 
     people do not. 

  F. This never happened. I don't exist. You don't exist. We
     don't know each other. There was never any /index.html 
     or /default.htm available here. I never asked for it, 
     and if anyone did ask for it, you just said "404". You 
     don't know how many people were looking for that file, 
     or whether it was 5KB or 17MB at any particular time.
One can easily understand how a user might urgently want for one or all of those, or even more stringent restrictions to be adhered to, under certain circumstances, but in some cases, the very nature of the beast is for a given server or cluster to maintain a certain degree of situational awareness, regarding the current state of user activity requested.

Beyond even that, in most cases, for a user to simply request the common courtesy of being forgotten might be unrealistic and completely ineffective from the outset.

   "Please don't track me, but here's my ID and password, now log me into my account."
I can think of several ways to interpret that. Worse yet, the fact that a user may have cookies turned on, and has sent the request in plain text, across ten other systems beyond my own control (all of which should also respect the user's wishes) completely defeats any realistic expectations of non-disclosure.

An honor system is certainly an admirable aspiration, but sending "do not track" requests by default also creates a general atmosphere of noise from users who may or may not be cognizant of the true nature of their actions.

The knee-jerk idea that cookies are bad isn't good enough. The idea that you can simply ask people to "be nice" also isn't good enough.

Dumb people are always going to be their own worst enemies, by playing the role of low hanging fruit to be preyed upon.

I've always felt that "do-not-track" requests were bullshit, just like the European cookie law was a silly white wash. (servers remember data, it's what they do. businesses exploit their customers for a profit, it's what they do.)

Just like having to opt into a "do-not-call" registry is bullshit. (no one wants to be cold-called by telemarketers, so why is this an opt-in thing?)

Just like anti-virus software is bullshit. (hey, how about you just don't execute code indiscriminately? doesn't that work too?)

The list goes on...

There are no comments on this comment yet.