News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yahoo ends support of “Do Not Track” by ori_b on Thursday May 01, 2014 @08:47PM (#7683549)
Do not track, as defined, was pretty meaningless. See the section of the RFC listing the exceptions:

    9.3.  Exceptions

    As a general guideline, exceptions to Do Not Track are warranted when
    commercial interests substantially outweigh privacy and verification
    interests.  The following activities are excepted:

    1.  Tracking of users who have explicitly consented to tracking, such
        as by enabling a checkbox in a preferences menu on the first-
        party website of the tracking service.
    2.  Data obtained by a third party exclusively on behalf of and for
        the use of a first party.
    3.  Data that is, with high confidence, not linkable to a specific
        user or user agent.  This exception includes statistical
        aggregates of protocol logs, such as pageview statistics, so long
        as the aggregator takes reasonable steps to ensure the data does
        not reveal information about individual users, user agents,
        devices, or log records.  It also includes highly non-unique data
        stored in the user agent, such as cookies used for advertising
        frequency capping or sequencing.  This exception does not include
        anonymized data, which recent work has shown to be often re-
        identifiable (see [Narayanan09] and [Narayanan08]).
    4.  Protocol logs, not aggregated across first parties, and subject
        to a two week retention period.
    5.  Protocol logs used solely for advertising fraud detection, and
        subject to a one month retention period.
    6.  Protocol logs used solely for security purposes such as intrusion
        detection and forensics, and subject to a six month retention
        period.
    7.  Protocol logs used solely for financial fraud detection, and
        subject to a six month retention period.

    To ensure data allowed for only specific uses is adequately
    protected, functional entities SHOULD implement strong internal
    controls.
Basically every advertising network would fall under 2 or 3.
Re:Yahoo ends support of “Do Not Track” by qwerty_asdf on Thursday May 01, 2014 @09:44PM (#7683740)
Awesome, this is exactly what I was too lazy to Google and dig up on my own. The plan pretty much shoots itself in the foot before it even leaves the gates.
Re:Yahoo ends support of “Do Not Track” by gcb0 on Thursday May 01, 2014 @10:15PM (#7683834)
ironically, yahoo is the ONLY big publisher adopting safeFrames. which effectively blocks any ability of the ad to identify the user, or set cookies as a fake-first-party.
Re:Yahoo ends support of “Do Not Track” by tdurden on Thursday May 01, 2014 @11:34PM (#7684012)
It is not really ironic. Yahoo! is the only/first one being honest about DNT to date (that I am aware of). Yahoo! is just bowing out of a deeply flawed spec.
Re:Yahoo ends support of “Do Not Track” by gcb0 on Friday May 02, 2014 @05:10PM (#7688178)
exactly why it is ironic!

they are the only one solving the privacy-while-showing-ads issue by using safeframes. then they drop DNT because it is a fallacy for the most part.

but they write that announcement in the worst possible way and everyone goes crazy.

Re:Yahoo ends support of “Do Not Track” by tdurden on Saturday May 03, 2014 @12:21AM (#7689557)
I misinterpreted your comment then! Thanks for the clarification.