Re:1Password Watchtower Mac App Integration
by r00fus on Thursday May 01, 2014 @11:50AM
(#7680497)
Problem: Aggregation and normalization might result in an empty set as contradictory rules prevent harmonization.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I think the parent comment is saying that 1Password would record the rules per site, not maintain a global list of rules that satisfies all sites. The latter would indeed yield an empty set, as some sites require a special character and some require no special characters.
Yes, exactly; for each site that 1Pwd can recognize as distinct, record the restrictions. Even share these restrictions. And perhaps people could put attributes on their password entry elements (or header metadata) that would describe the limitations of their password systems, so it wouldn't be specific to any one password manager; then, too, they could retire their terrible, terrible, terrible client-side strength checking crap.