Talking to employees, or even partners, where the other party is responsible for understanding the general mental framework and needs a precise answer to a precise question, is very different to talking up the status hierarchy.
When you speak to an investor who expects a "crisp" response to an arbitrary knee-jerk question they just thought up, which buries in it several wrong assumptions, the correct response is to reverse engineer that, and address the assumptions themselves, while conveying a whole host of other attributes at the same time. Essentially you need to decode the other person's mental framework and encode your message on their terms. If the inferential distance is significant, there is no way this can be done in real-time. But what I worry about here is that the more off-center the entrepreneur's mental model, (which is what you need for innovation), and the more complex the execution, the harder it is to cross the chasm to communicating with an up-the-status-chain interlocutor that expects everything to be in bite-sized insights they can digest.
An observation here is that, in one case a correct answer is a direct answer, and in the other case a correct answer is an indirect answer.
the YC interview is particularly error-prone in that regard, as you don't know who you are going to be speaking to in advance, so you have little means for preparing. That setup (plus the 10 minutes limit) is a recipe for randomness. Essentialy you get good interviews if the two parties happen to have similar mental contexts, but it doesn't seem that YC takes that into account at all. On the other hand, it also favours mainstream mental models and simple-to-explain ideas, which seems directly contradictory to what YC wants to achieve.
However I don't see how convincing a non-motivated arbitrary person of a fairly complicated idea in 10 minutes is highly correlated to all the other contexts a founder has to deal with. Sure it's a great attribute if you can have it, but it's one in a long list.
Big ideas are usually really simple to explain to users. Google Search is basically "Type anything into a text box, and we'll give you answers." Ideas that are complicated rarely become big (as in widely adopted by many people).
I wonder if you could expand on that? I also wonder if you've observed whether or not people want to be "concise" with their goals. In my experience, success has been built around doing certain little things really well. For example, my business is successful because I'm really good at building a certain type of landing page. Yes, there is a lot that surrounds it, but it's basically just this one thing that makes it work.
The issue of scope is something that everybody confronts when running a business. Any additional insight you could add would be appreciated.
Thank you for your comment.
Warmly,
Jacob
> I wonder if you could expand on that?"
This is really selling. And it's something that comes in handy in business in every situation. If you can't concisely explain what your product can do for someone (either in person or in print) through marketing or salesmanship you won't make the sale unless you have some overwhelming advantage in some other area that holds people's interest (or little competition or maybe a super low price).
Obviously in a HN comment there is no way to get into explaining how to be a good sales person in a few sentences. And while I could suggest books [1] the truth is you either have to have some experience and/or you have to be a "born" salesman. Or both.
Edit: [1] I don't mean "I" could suggest specific books. Because I've never read books on sales. But I have closed large and small deals, against formidable opponents (right out of college, an example is trained IBM sales people) and I never read a single book on sales. But I do know there are books that can be purchased on selling and sales obviously.
Used copies start at 1 cent, and I closed a lot of deals with the contents of this book. Very easy to read, with short humorous chapters.
This is always the case at YC like places.
Please don't sign comments, especially with your url. They're already signed with your username. If other users want to learn more about you, they can click on it to see your profile.
This is a symptom of a more general problem: people severely underestimate how difficult it is to convey an idea to another human being such that they actually understand it. Being able to do so is no small task, and I wish more people would recognize the value of this skill.