News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by Jtsummers on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @09:14PM (#7677592)
A friend of mine used to rant about cellphones in theaters, and thought theaters should install jammers (as in, he was actually surprised that none had done this yet). The fact is, they're a primary communication device for many people. Who knows when you might receive a call that you have to take (for certain jobs or with situations concerning family or friends), or when you need to make a phone call (see the Aurora shooting or the recent one in FL for violent examples, but even a heart attack or some other medical emergency). Jammers just aren't a good idea for 99.999% of the situations people suggest using them.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by ryandrake on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @11:27PM (#7678038)
Somehow, back before cell phones were invented, we all miraculously managed to live our lives without having constant access to a telephone. If you needed to call someone, you stepped away from whatever you were doing and called them. If Aunt Mabel had a heart attack, you'd find out about it, just not 500ms after it happened. If someone wasn't happy with how you filled out your TPS report at work, you'd go into the office in the morning and fix it.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by mseebach on Thursday May 01, 2014 @04:16AM (#7678765)
> Somehow, back before cell phones were invented, we all miraculously managed to live our lives without having constant access to a telephone.

We also miraculously managed to live without plumbing and electricity. That doesn't mean that life isn't a lot better with it.

I have family who work in health care. They spend a lot of their time at home, on call. Back in the landline days, they were tied to their phone. They literally couldn't take the dog for a walk around the block, lest they'd miss a call. Today, thanks to mobile phones, they can run errands and even go to the movies.

The problem isn't cellphones, the problem is that some people are assholes and movie theaters are too meek to enforce a no-asshole policy. If people were routinely ejected from theatres for being disruptive people would behave better.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by PhasmaFelis on Thursday May 01, 2014 @03:00AM (#7678627)
> we all miraculously managed to live our lives without having constant access to a telephone.

Well, except for the people who actually, literally died because the doctor who could have saved them couldn't be reached in time.

Doctors on call had pagers before anyone else had even heard of them, much less cellphones. Are you actually taking the position that barring surgeons and other emergency personnel from, not just entering, but coming anywhere near a movie theater is a reasonable solution to the problem of the occasional jerk disrupting your entertainment?

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by InclinedPlane on Thursday May 01, 2014 @05:25AM (#7678903)
"We all" who? Not everyone. Doctors have carried pagers since pagers were invented. Some people do actually have a legitimate reason to be on call 24/7. Not everyone, sure, and most people are too connected to their work these days. But don't pretend as though being disconnected is a virtue for everyone. For some people in some professions being disconnected can cost lives or can cost thousands or millions of dollars per minute in losses.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by lotu on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @11:50PM (#7678117)
The problem is we are dismantling our land line network. So if you don't have cell phone there might not by any phone in the building that works. Next what about emergency workers? They need to be able to be contacted. Or what about people on call for their jobs? All of these things could be blocked by jammers and the idea that we survived once without it unconvincing we survived once without vacancies and antibiotics too.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by frandroid on Thursday May 01, 2014 @01:01AM (#7678318)
Huh? Where are "we" dismantling our landline network?
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by kalleboo on Thursday May 01, 2014 @07:48AM (#7679221)
In Sweden we are. After a big storm a few years ago knocked out the phone lines to some remote homes, the telco calculated that it was cheaper to let them use 4G than to repair kilometers of telephone poles.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by exhilaration on Thursday May 01, 2014 @11:25PM (#7683985)
Same thing in parts of New Jersey after Hurricane Sandy, Verizon refused to rebuild the landlines and installed 4G base stations instead.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by frandroid on Saturday May 03, 2014 @10:49AM (#7690993)
Whoa. I get Sweden, Scandinavia has been topping mobile penetration for a while, but Jersey... Stunning.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by superuser2 on Thursday May 01, 2014 @01:45AM (#7678434)
Are you being deliberately obtuse?

Every payphone I've ever seen in my lifetime has been removed.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by frandroid on Saturday May 03, 2014 @10:51AM (#7690997)
Payphones are endpoints, the network is much more than that. Except for the few examples listed in another answer, most of the infrastructure is still intact, i.e. you can get a landline in your home if you want one.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by DigitalJack on Thursday May 01, 2014 @02:24AM (#7678546)
There are usually a couple near grocery stores where I live.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by throwaway0010 on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @10:16PM (#7677833)
But some theaters DO block cellphones -- by encasing the venue in a faraday cage. It's possible to buy paint with metallic bits to block radio.

Broadcasting to jam is illegal. It is not illegal to build a room in which cellphones do not work, nor should it be.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by Jtsummers on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @10:31PM (#7677890)
I'll make the claim that I've not noticed reception issues in theaters in at least the last 5 years. My use-case is typically texting (usually with the other members of my group, things like "Hey, I'm on the 5th row up") though, but even then I usually see 2+ bars, sufficient for voice calls.

My apartment has worse reception than that (I can make calls from my sunroom, nowhere else).

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by neil1 on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @11:00PM (#7677971)
You can buy and install a cellphone extender for your house.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by thrownaway2424 on Thursday May 01, 2014 @12:47AM (#7678291)
Yes, it's a true fact that you can pay money for the privilege of extending the cell phone provider's network, while also paying the backhaul the cell phone company's traffic over your internet link, while also paying the cell phone for their "service" that you have to personally install and operate. I have no idea why people think this is an acceptable scenario.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by wtracy on Thursday May 01, 2014 @02:08AM (#7678498)
The providers apparently assume that you're already paying for "unlimited" internet.

Also, these access points pair with your device and don't provide bandwidth to other random devices, so at least you're not providing free backhaul for random passersby.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by Jtsummers on Thursday May 01, 2014 @09:38AM (#7679620)
I got one of these for my apartment, worked great for 2 years but I could never add other people's numbers to it like advertised. It just paired with my phone and only used my internet connection for SMS/calls as long as I had wifi on (it would use my internet connection for 3g data but that would kill my battery and be silly to use with a phone that has wifi, it would also count against your quota if you had a limited plan).
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by tsomctl on Thursday May 01, 2014 @02:09AM (#7678501)
There are other ones which are just a simple amplifier, not a whole base station. There's one antennae on the outside, another smaller one on the inside, and whatever signal it picks up one one antennae, it retransmits on the other with more power. Obviously the antennaes are directional so you don't get feedback, and there might be some more complicated filtering too.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by neil1 on Thursday May 01, 2014 @10:39PM (#7683890)
It's a solution to a problem, that he faces. I understand that it makes no sense, but sometimes you have to do things that make no sense or switch carriers.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by throwaway0010 on Thursday May 01, 2014 @10:04AM (#7679778)
I think you may have misunderstood. "Some" is certainly not "all" or even "most." We are discussing legality, not whether the practice is common.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by mentalhealth on Thursday May 01, 2014 @02:17AM (#7678528)
Back in the day (I haven't been in a while, unfortunately, so I don't know the current status), at nicer theatres and at the opera, they had a service available for emergency personnel (doctors, et cetera) where they'd take your pager, put a tag with your seat number on it (and also typically you'd be seated on an aisle), and they come fetch you if your pager went off. Worked great with minimal disruption to patrons... though the definition of "emergency" was fairly narrow, and this likely wouldn't work if patrons were insisting on it for family phone calls and so on.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by mhb on Thursday May 01, 2014 @09:04AM (#7679444)
It would work fine if this was a paid service. People could decide what "emergency" was worth being notified about. That would also give the theater some incentive to enforce a no-device policy.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by vacri on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @10:00PM (#7677769)
If it's known that the theatre is a phone dead zone, you can step outside the theatre and make the call. If someone's having a heart attack, you have a whole theatre full of people that you can pull resources from.

A car driving around is a secret dead zone that punishes you for being nearby, even if you're not transgressing any social norms or traffic laws. Sitting on a park bench nearby? Hell, even being a passenger in a vehicle? That's the problem - he's being an indiscriminate vigilante.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by stevekinney on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @10:16PM (#7677832)
I think the point was that if a theatre installed jammers, then patrons could not receive calls. Yea, I get that no one wants to overhear someone having a long chat with their significant other right as the plot line thickens, but a doctor on call or a parent who's kid is just got hurt at the baby sitter might appreciate being able to receive a call or text while their phone is on silent. They can then step out of the theatre in order to take the call or call back.

That said, I totally agree with you on your main point. This is often a counter argument when people suggest that mobile devices should be disabled when the car is in motion (which isn't necessarily the same thing as jamming). Often, when I'm driving, my wife is looking up directions or letting a family member know that we're near.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by vacri on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @11:00PM (#7677975)
A doctor on-call can go without going to the movies. I say this having been on-call (not as a doctor) myself. When you're on-call, your life is seriously curtailed. You can't drink, you have to be within range of tools to do your work, you have to be immediately accessible. Being on-call sucks, but it's no reason to argue against passive signal blocking in theatres.

As for the babysitter, deal with it. If you're not contactable for 90 minutes, you're not contactable for 90 minutes. This perma-connectivity is an entirely new phenomenon, and there's no absolute need for it. Essentially this argument is saying that the parent's inability to deal with lack of connectivity is a convenience which trumps the general theatre-going public's convenience of not having people talking on the phone, or who light up the people behind them because they're bored with the movie and are playing online.

Being uncontactable for a short period is not the horror that it's made out to be in these arguments. The good old argument that someone can't sit through a lecture without connectivity "in case Auntie Mabel dies", but of course it's just a cover for having phone access for other things. If one were to believe the excuses that get trotted out, you'd be forgiven for thinking that human mortality had skyrocketed since the public acceptance of mobile phones :)

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by PhasmaFelis on Thursday May 01, 2014 @03:15AM (#7678657)
It's true that the world doesn't end if Dr. Jones isn't allowed to go the movies, or if Mr. and Mrs. Smith get to watch the end credits before finding out that their baby's in an ambulance. But the world also doesn't end if you have to suffer through a rude teenager on the phone for a minute and a half. You talk like your leisure experience is an absolute moral imperative, but everyone else's is just frivolous goofing off and easily sacrificed. Why is that?
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by biff on Thursday May 01, 2014 @05:10AM (#7678875)
The goal of a movie theatre is leisure experience. If you know a movie is 90+ minutes, and there's a significant likelihood of you or your devices causing a disruption to the other 100 people in the audience in 90+ minutes...

On a different note, me and my friend and his wife went to see Roger Waters perform The Wall a couple years back. The tickets said "No photography", but the band was very careful to say "When you take photos, please make sure the flash on your cameras is off. There are effects during our production that camera flashes will disrupt." I'm paraphrasing, but they were projecting video on the bricks that were assembled onstage as part of the performance. Sure enough, not minutes into the first set, flash flash flash flash flash.

My friends were taking photos. I made sure not to look over at them.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by vidarh on Thursday May 01, 2014 @07:01AM (#7679108)
I've been to the cinema several hundred times over the last decade. There was a period we used to go 1-2 every week. In that time, I've never once been distracted by anyones phone going off. Maybe half a dozen times I've been momentarily annoyed by someone checking their phone with an overly bright screen. That's it.

It would seem letting people have a signal doesn't have to be a problem.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by PhasmaFelis on Thursday May 01, 2014 @01:58PM (#7681506)
> The goal of a movie theatre is leisure experience. If you know a movie is 90+ minutes, and there's a significant likelihood of you or your devices causing a disruption to the other 100 people in the audience in 90+ minutes...

I think your definition of "disruption" may not be entirely reasonable. It's one thing if someone is sitting there having a chat during the movie, but if a person quietly getting up and excusing themselves (in response to an unheard vibration in their pocket) is unacceptable, then we're going have to ban anyone who sits down to a three-and-a-half-hour film with a Jumbo Big Gulp from the concession counter.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by biff on Thursday May 01, 2014 @04:55PM (#7682637)
If that was the reaction to an incoming cellphone call, every time by every person, I don't think anybody would have a problem with cellphones in public spaces.
Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by stevekinney on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @11:26PM (#7678035)
Yea, I could probably list a few hundred examples and you could probably shoot each and every one of them down on an individual level. Great. The larger point is that in the aggregate, there are enough individual situations that would be disrupted by jammers in the theatre that it would outweigh the nexus between the number of times someone is going to be inconvenienced by a conversation during a movie and the number of times someone is actually rude enough to pick up the phone during a movie. At the end of the day, it's a cost-benefit analysis.

If a movie theatre did in fact install jammers each parent concerned about their kid (yea, it's probably not a true emergency, but subjective perception matters) or each doctor (I'm thinking more about delivering babies, which can mean being on call for weeks at a time, than an ER doctor) might choose to skip the movie. The end result is that that the theatre will likely take a hit on their profits. That's not a compelling reason to invest in installing a jammer.

The whole "we survived just fine without constant connectivity" argument is flawed. Yea, we did a lot of things without modern technology. We got along fine without movies, driving to the movies, mobile phones, the Internet, or arguing on the Internet about the need for mobile phone access during a movie.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by vacri on Thursday May 01, 2014 @12:15AM (#7678198)
The 'we got along fine without instant connectivity' argument is a counter to the overwrought life-and-death-situation arguments in general. It's not about being a luddite, it's about keeping perspective.

Have another read of my comment, and you'll see in the middle of it that I'm saying that it's an argument of conveniences. It's convenient for a parent to have instant connectivity in case the babysitter calls, just as it's convenient for the audience to enjoy the movie they paid for without distractions. You say the theatre would take a financial hit for installing blocking devices, yet the more common trope is that the major annoyance in a theatre is people on phones - you could just as easily argue that they'd get a financial benefit from it. Doctors specifically on-call to deliver babies aren't much of a market segment to a movie theatre.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by akiselev on Thursday May 01, 2014 @03:44AM (#7678705)
> It's not about being a luddite, it's about keeping perspective.

You clearly have no perspective.

I'd prefer my next trauma surgeon can relax and take in half a movie before he is called in on his pager to try and save my life, of which I have one that will be entirely in his hands. I don't give a fuck if you miss a couple of minutes of a movie that cost you $15 or even if it meant myself never being able to go into a movie theater again.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by derefr on Thursday May 01, 2014 @04:29AM (#7678793)
Maybe you care a lot about your life, and thereby about the quality-of-life of trauma surgeons. Do you think the movie theatre does?

What's so wrong with having places that can only be attended by people who are fine with nobody will be able to reach them? Businesses don't have to serve everybody; in fact, selling exactly that escapism--that only people in certain classes and professions can afford the time to experience--is exactly the business model theatres. It is also the business model of cruise-lines and travel agencies.

If a trauma surgeon wants to see a movie, they can wait for it to come out on Netflix. Just so: if a trauma surgeon wants to go to the beach and sip mai-tais, they can find a public one within an hour's drive of the hospital.

(Note that this is all assuming that being on-call is a sensible thing to have in society. We really need to get ourselves enough employed doctors that we can guarantee we'll only need some of them at any given time, so the rest can actually stay home and sleep.)

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by akiselev on Thursday May 01, 2014 @05:31AM (#7678914)
There's absolutely nothing wrong with that. I can't wait until movie theaters pop up that advertise walls covered with metallic paint to block cellular RF. As someone who dislikes push notifications and refuses to work in any profession with the concept of being "on call," I will go to those almost all the time. And when my surgeon isn't on call, he'll be even more relaxed!

Thing is, I just can't think of a single scenario where the rights of the many to enjoy uninterrupted entertainment in every theater outweigh the rights of everyone else to be in constant communication with whomever they chose to, for whatever reason they chose to. Regardless if they are a surgeon, parent, or just a loud douchebag in a movie theater.

So until these faraday cage theaters start popping up, if you want the movie theater without the rest of civilization, you'll just have to take a generator and projector to a National Park or start it yourself.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by vacri on Thursday May 01, 2014 @10:13AM (#7679823)
Rights? What rights? You're talking about conveniences here, supplied by a private entity, not rights. You don't have a right to watch a movie with guaranteed phone access any more than you have a right to watch a movie not being illuminated by the bright screen of the phone from some idiot in front of you. You don't even have a right to watch a movie in the first place.

Seriously, get some perspective here.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by vacri on Thursday May 01, 2014 @10:07AM (#7679796)
Since we're doing ridiculous hypotheticals here, I'd rather the entire movie theatre having a relaxing, fun time with no interruptions or rude phone users, meaning that they leave the movie happy rather than irritated, less likely to have an accident on the way home and hence need a trauma surgeon in the first place. Ounce of prevention is better than a pound of cure and all that.

As for perspective, you are right that life-and-death on-call people should be using pagers rather than phones, but you completely miss the point that you can get pagers that work on a higher frequency than the phone system. Your precious trauma surgeon can still have a pager that works in a theatre while disallowing phone use, since Faraday cages can be tuned to work on different frequencies. Pagers should be used because a pager service comes with a guaranteed SLA, and SMS services do not.

And frankly, I don't give a fuck about your ignorance, just don't use it to angrily insult me when I've done nothing to you.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by Jtsummers on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @10:27PM (#7677872)
Thanks, receiving calls is really the big one for me. I know a lot of people working in fields requiring them to be on call 24x7 unless they're on leave. A 2 hour delay in calling back is just barely tolerable for most of them, and unacceptable for some. It'd suck to have to stop enjoying something outside a couple vacations a year because some people are inconsiderate and other people can't tune them out.

That said, making calls to emergency services, if you have to run outside to make that call, you've lost 30 seconds or a couple minutes. And you can't follow their directions in aiding the person because you're outside, and the victim(s) are inside. That's assuming it's not an attacker who would prevent you from leaving in the first place.

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by vacri on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @11:03PM (#7677984)
That's assuming it's not an attacker who would prevent you from leaving in the first place.

Is this really such a pandemic in the US these days?

Re:Driver caught using cell phone jamming device by Jtsummers on Thursday May 01, 2014 @10:14AM (#7679831)
Theater shootings and mass shootings, not really. But shootings do happen, sometimes over the dumbest crap, and by people you wouldn't expect ([EDIT: retired] police officer in FL in a theater, a veteran shot a woman at a gas station here in GA [1]). Shootings aren't nearly common enough, though, to justify a ban on jammers. But emergency situations do come up, especially in a country of 300 million people and some 40k theaters [2], each with several screens. It just strikes me as irresponsible and unnecessary to insist on such a hardline ban for the sake of shutting out a few rude jerks.

[1] http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2012/12/05/woman-k...

[2] http://chartsbin.com/view/32k -- I'm assuming this is accurate