Re:US Supreme Court reverses patent judges again in 9-0 deci...
by rayiner on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @04:07PM
(#7676045)
This is an excellent summary of the Octane Fitness decision. I'll quote two bits of relevant language that lay out the standards the Supreme court has established.
"Under the standard announced today, a district court may award fees in the rare case in which a party's unreasonable conduct-while not necessarily independently sanctionable-is nonetheless so 'exceptional' as to justify an award of fees." (Slip. Op. at 5).
"Something less than 'bad faith,' we believe, suffices to mark a case as 'exceptional.'" (Slip. Op. at 6).
In other words, the court interpreted section 285 to allow fee-shifting in cases that are not so weak that the court would be justified in sanctioning the plaintiffs under Rule 11 for pursuing a frivolous claim, or in cases where plaintiffs use tactics that do not quite rise to the level that would be sanctionable for bad faith.
However, the Court did not give as much guidance to lower courts as one might have hoped. The Court stated that a case that is weak to a degree short of "sanctionable" may be the subject of fee shifting. It has not said how much stronger than "sanctionable" a case can be before awarding fees is an abuse of discretion on the part of the District Court. This is a question that will probably be raised to and resolved by the Federal Circuit in the coming years.
"Under the standard announced today, a district court may award fees in the rare case in which a party's unreasonable conduct-while not necessarily independently sanctionable-is nonetheless so 'exceptional' as to justify an award of fees." (Slip. Op. at 5).
"Something less than 'bad faith,' we believe, suffices to mark a case as 'exceptional.'" (Slip. Op. at 6).
In other words, the court interpreted section 285 to allow fee-shifting in cases that are not so weak that the court would be justified in sanctioning the plaintiffs under Rule 11 for pursuing a frivolous claim, or in cases where plaintiffs use tactics that do not quite rise to the level that would be sanctionable for bad faith.
However, the Court did not give as much guidance to lower courts as one might have hoped. The Court stated that a case that is weak to a degree short of "sanctionable" may be the subject of fee shifting. It has not said how much stronger than "sanctionable" a case can be before awarding fees is an abuse of discretion on the part of the District Court. This is a question that will probably be raised to and resolved by the Federal Circuit in the coming years.