News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Absurdity of LinkedIn by yahelc on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @11:04AM (#7673750)
I noticed this the other day -- while logged in, LinkedIn insisted I must upgrade to Premium in order to see the last name of the person whose profile I was looking at (which of course, was publicly once I logged out).
Re:The Absurdity of LinkedIn by hga on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @11:25AM (#7673908)
Might you find some value from the person, and LinkedIn, knowing you looked at that profile?

I can't offhand think of any, but that's one difference between these two use cases.

Re:The Absurdity of LinkedIn by antjanus on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @12:04PM (#7674218)
Yeah, small bits of value.

Before any interview, I'd check out the people I'd go see. They would know I looked at their profile (which shows interest and due diligence) and if they had not checked out my profile already, they would now which helps me imprint on them better, if that makes sense. I'd also check out the people I'd be working with, and if they see that I checked out their profile, they'd probably check mine out too (just to see who this guy is that visited their profile) thus that makes me stand out a bit and we're on a better footing.

On the flip side, if an interviewer checks me out before I go in for an interview, it shows actual interest and makes me consider the company more seriously. So I actually appreciate it when an interviewer drops by my linkedin and I can see that they did. It's a plus. Like a pre-connect before an interview.

Outside of that, I'm not sure.

Re:The Absurdity of LinkedIn by scrabble on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @12:22PM (#7674340)
I can think of one. My current director viewed my profile and didn't contact me during my employment with my last employer.

I took a look at the company he worked for and contacted him myself about an opportunity. Now I work for him (he's an excellent leader too).

Had I not seen that he viewed my profile, I wouldn't be working for his company now.

As an aside, I will generally always view profiles in an incognito window.

Re:The Absurdity of LinkedIn by lstamour on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @11:38AM (#7674013)
Except anonymous users get the benefit of being both anonymous and able to view the profile. LinkedIn pushes users to either upgrade or sign out. Works for me, I don't like signing in often either.
Re:The Absurdity of LinkedIn by andypants on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @01:10PM (#7674666)
They only really push users to upgrade. They don't let you know that you can view the full profile if you sign out. That's just an obscure (possibly temporary) workaround.
Re:The Absurdity of LinkedIn by samstave on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @11:39AM (#7674016)
I saw this recently to, where i had done a google search of the person: the google search result showed their full nam in the actual link to linkedin - after clickingto go to the linkedin page, from the full name link, it withheld the last name.

Idiocy.

Re:The Absurdity of LinkedIn by shostack on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @03:02PM (#7675547)
Isn't that considered cloaking and a direct violation of Google's Webmaster guidelines? https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/66355

That's the kind of thing expertsexchange.com was busted for amongst other sites. Or is LinkedIn simply "above the law" because of their search volume?

Re:The Absurdity of LinkedIn by Netminder_EE on Thursday May 01, 2014 @04:56PM (#7682644)
DISCLAIMER: I'm Experts Exchange's senior volunteer administrator.

That's just one of the things EE was busted for. For logged in members, they would see the pages from a Google SERP one would expect to see; for non-members (or those who weren't logged in), they would see a page that said "sign up". It's not unprecedented -- the New York Times does the same thing -- but the way EE did it (over strong objections from the user community) was singularly creepy. That EE's competitors had Matt Cutts on speed dial just hastened the imposition of the Panda et seq. penalties.

The good news -- at least, for those of us who aren't natural born haters -- is that a change in management has resulted in the paywall coming down, and the penalties imposed are slowly but surely being overcome.

Re:The Absurdity of LinkedIn by acchow on Saturday May 03, 2014 @05:51PM (#7692466)
That is the precise inverse of what LinkedIn is doing.

Never used LinkedIn before, no account - see exactly what Google SERP shows.

Never used EE before, no account - you get a page asking you to "sign up" instead of the Google SERP page.

Re:The Absurdity of LinkedIn by Netminder_EE on Saturday May 03, 2014 @07:48PM (#7692757)
With respect, that's not true: http://www.ee-stuff.com/images/LoggedOutView.png

You DO get a message asking you to join just above the question, but nothing else.

Re:The Absurdity of LinkedIn by samstave on Thursday May 01, 2014 @11:28PM (#7683993)
They still exist?
Re:The Absurdity of LinkedIn by Netminder_EE on Saturday May 03, 2014 @07:50PM (#7692763)
Why wouldn't EE exist? Despite the best efforts of some well-known bloggers whose site wouldn't exist if it had to depend solely on actual income, EE exists because it has a business model that DOES work.