More the latter: there are particular things we wish people would do.
I don't think we've funded anyone to work on #2 yet.
I don't remember pikluk.com, but the ideas on that list are deliberately vague. There are a lot of possible permutations, some good and some bad. If we didn't fund you, it wasn't necessarily (or even probably) because we were waiting for someone else to do it.
Why not also add a link to "Startup Ideas" beside "Feature requests" so anyone can contribute ideas and vote on them?
Re:A New Experiment: The RFS
by colins_pride on Sunday August 16, 2009 @06:16PM
(#766872)
This is one of those ideas that seems so obviously good after the fact that it just makes one marvel
This is a great idea. I've often wished that pg's original ideas article was updated more regularly but your suggestion would be a nice alternative to giving pg more work to do, especially given how poorly we pay him.
"Your idea is great, but we'll wait for someone with a better pedigree to work on it" - Did the rejection letter/mail explicitly indicate that ? Or is that your own conclusion ?
I also wonder what happened to idea #2 on this list: http://ycombinator.com/ideas.html
Seemed like pikluk.com applied to solve precisely that (even before the list was published) but we got rejected, then exhausted our savings, burned out and just quietly returned to our day jobs, yet no YC-funded solution emerged up to date. Being rejected is one thing, but getting "Your idea is great, but we'll wait for someone with a better pedigree to work on it" message hurts much more.