News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:X Could Learn a Lot from Vista, Windows 7 by planckscnst on Sunday August 16, 2009 @08:30AM (#766011)
He clearly has no idea what he's talking about, but he does have two points.

1) Resizing a window shouldn't cause a crash - this is true, but very specific to his setup; most users will not experience the behavior he saw here.

2) If X crashes (which it inevitably does from time to time), it should not also kill every app you have going. This one is a huge huge problem.

Re:X Could Learn a Lot from Vista, Windows 7 by jacquesm on Sunday August 16, 2009 @09:07AM (#766046)
I've been using X for about 5 years straight now, before that other versions of it (mostly SGI stuff).

I've had exactly one crash. In all that time. This machine is on 24x7 and on average has 10-15 (large) windows open on two screens (soon to be 4).

X is absolutely rock solid in my experience, but as with all anecdotal evidence that doesn't mean much.

When you start playing around with custom window managers and all kinds of other esoterics I don't doubt that it is possible to crash X (the time I did it it was when I tried to set up an X server across 4 displays on 4 different computers, http://pics.ww.com/v/jacques/projects/screen/dscf1072.jpg.ht... ).

I was pissed off but I was really asking for it.

Re:X Could Learn a Lot from Vista, Windows 7 by christopherolah on Sunday August 16, 2009 @12:01PM (#766224)
Seconded. X has only crashed once or twice in the last 3 years of me using it.

This may be anecdotal evidence, but then again so is the article.

Re:X Could Learn a Lot from Vista, Windows 7 by windsurfer on Sunday August 16, 2009 @09:16AM (#766056)
I tried to set up an X server across 4 displays on 4 different computers

Maybe Vista 7 should learn a few things from X...

Re:X Could Learn a Lot from Vista, Windows 7 by wglb on Sunday August 16, 2009 @11:39AM (#766203)
I routinely operate with 50 open, often as many as 100. Never had an X crash in the two years been with this setup.
Re:X Could Learn a Lot from Vista, Windows 7 by thras on Sunday August 16, 2009 @09:59AM (#766100)
Try turning on Compiz. You'll see some crashing.
Re:X Could Learn a Lot from Vista, Windows 7 by dhimes on Sunday August 16, 2009 @12:57PM (#766297)
I use Compiz all the time, and I have no problems with crashes. I like the effects, but there is one that is very helpful: alt+mousescroll allows me to change the transparency of the selected window. As I don't have multiple monitors, I find this very convenient when coding (or any other task where I have to refer to information in another window).

I also like "rolling the windows up" like a window shade (available on some themes. I dunno...I just do!

Re:X Could Learn a Lot from Vista, Windows 7 by apotheon on Monday August 17, 2009 @12:14PM (#768392)
That's the first time I've ever run across something Compiz does that would actually be useful to me over a non-compositing window manager.
Re:X Could Learn a Lot from Vista, Windows 7 by apotheon on Sunday August 16, 2009 @12:29PM (#766263)
Why would I do that? What does Compiz do for me? It's just whirling cubes and wavy windows.
Re:X Could Learn a Lot from Vista, Windows 7 by kidko on Sunday August 16, 2009 @03:55PM (#766602)
I did that a few months ago, actually. The only crash I had was because I forgot to update my driver for the new video card I got. Since then, it's been as stable as my pre-Compiz system.