News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by gbog on Monday April 28, 2014 @10:19AM (#7660075)
In this discussion I very rarely see mentioned how heavy are cars. Since when do we need multi tons machine to move a being that is usually below 100kg from a to b? Here in northern China, many people have very small egg-cars, which are nothing more than an electric bike with a thin shell for the cold, and this is much less likely to kill someone by accident.

I think we have been under a very strong brain washing so that we all believe a nice car is big and has this and that. Maybe these car ads will be seen in 20 years the same way we see cigarette ads right now: dangerous brain washing by a lobby gone crazy.

(Edited slightly to avoid unfortunate pun)

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by pinaceae on Monday April 28, 2014 @10:56AM (#7660321)
because it is a multi-purpose vehicle. i drive a car to work, single passenger. i drive the car to buy stuff, with my wife, 2 passengers, plus hauling stuff in the trunk. i drive the car to various places on the weekend, wife plus kid plus shit in the trunk.

i bought it to cover multiple transportation scenarios I encounter on a weekly basis. it also has a certain size to protect me in an accident. bumping into something at 30mph needs a certain amount of crumple zone to make it survivable. physics are hard to beat.

and I haven't killed anyone so far with my car - and I've driven on multiple continents, on and offroad.

no lobby needed.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by bertil on Monday April 28, 2014 @01:14PM (#7661343)
Actually, with self-driving cars, it’s likely that those four activity could be handled by different vehicles that you would only rent for the time you need them. If the law allows them to drive empty, they could go to the next user on their own, and reduce both waste parking, and inefficiencies like the ones you describe.

Such plans are however more likely to happen in areas where those issues are more dire (concentrated living) and where non-ownership is already commonly accepted: bike-sharing already exists in NY. Not sure where you are, but I’m assuming you don’t have city-car-sharing there. This discrepancy can come off as a result of lobbying: car companies typically appear hostile to selling a lot less cars to sharing platform operators. I know for a fact there was a lot of lobbying involved in some cases, but I doubt that was the key issues in most places where ‘transportation alternatives’ isn’t used.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by pinaceae on Monday April 28, 2014 @01:56PM (#7661694)
sure, but this why ownership as a concept is actually quite nice - i can decide right now to do something with my car. i don't need to plan ahead. i am not dependent on anybody else. i gladly pay for that luxury.
Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by prawn on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @01:05AM (#7665068)
When you travel abroad, does it trouble you that it's not your plane? Eventually, the majority of people won't care. Some will pay a premium to have a dedicated car or service level, but I would happily be rid of mine.

The ability to book the type of car I need (van to move something large, ute to deliver dirt/gravel, tiny car to commute, 4WD for a family camping trip) as the default way of thinking can't come soon enough for me.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by kd0amg on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @08:10AM (#7666369)
When you travel abroad, does it trouble you that it's not your plane?

Actually, it is quite a hassle to have to operate on the airline's schedule rather than on my own, not to mention having to make travel arrangements weeks in advance. It's just that owning and operating an airplane myself is too expensive for me. Since moving to Boston, so is owning a car. That said, I am definitely not planning to switch to rental bicycles.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by TulliusCicero on Monday April 28, 2014 @04:20PM (#7662697)
Yes, and surely some people (particularly in less dense suburbs and rural areas) will continue to own cars. They will just be self-driving cars, because manually operated cars will be illegal.
Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by mcherm on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @09:39AM (#7666861)
You write: > because manually operated cars will be illegal.

I have a question for you. How many years after the introduction of the gasoline powered automobile did it take before horse-drawn vehicles became illegal on the roads?

Near where I live (eastern Pennsylvania, USA) one still encounters a horse-and-buggy occasionally, especially near Amish areas. And a few roads (interstates and limited access highways) are specifically posted for motor vehicles only.

I posit that there will be a LONG period in which manually operated cars will share the road with self-driving cars.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by pinaceae on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @09:43AM (#7666894)
everything always needs to be illegal. ban this, ban that. not exactly a libertarian, but man, is there no other way in your little world?

what if i enjoy driving a car? what about motorcycles? you want to ban them too? oldtimers, just for spite? sugar drinks? sweets? alcohol? drugs?

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by alwaysdoit on Monday April 28, 2014 @02:14PM (#7661827)
Isn't buying a car that is able to handle a bunch of different hypothetical future scenarios planning ahead?
Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by pinaceae on Monday April 28, 2014 @02:58PM (#7662115)
sure, but i do it once and then i have peace of mind. i have a car at my disposal, 24/7/365.

should i book a car for the weekend? a last minute shopping tour? etc. etc. etc.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by pyoung on Monday April 28, 2014 @08:51PM (#7664175)
Have you ever used Lyft. In my experience (SF), it literally takes minutes for a car to show up. More often than not, I am still looking for may keys/wallet/jacket or brushing my teeth when the car gets here. I imagine an autonomous car service would be even faster, as car availability could be highly tuned to demand (Lyft and Uber are using comparatively crude methods of demand/availability management, surge pricing).

As others have mentioned, the car-sharing model works best in urban areas, and no one is suggesting that we ban individuals from owning cars. But I will also add that we have spent the last 100 years building infrastructure and public spaces to accommodate for a car-centric society, but this has had a negative impact on people who prefer other forms of transportation. Public transportation is severely underfunded and inadequate in most places, pedestrians and bikers are getting mowed down by reckless drivers, tons of public land is being poorly utilized as parking space, and our air is getting polluted to unprecedented levels. Your "peace of mind" comes at a high cost to the rest of society. Autonomous cars are not a silver bullet for all of these problems by any means, but they can go a long way in getting us to a better place with most of these issues.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by gbog on Monday April 28, 2014 @08:11PM (#7664011)
Ok I actually have the same usage pattern as you and I have a minivan, which I think optimizes quite well the size.

Also, you say you didn't kill anyone. Great but how much room did cities you crossed have to plan for you? How many other non driving people had to reduce their living space for this? Not counting fossil fuel, materials used, etc.

Safety is probably the mask used by this light to hide their agenda, and it is clever. Buy maybe it is completely made up. Maybe everyone would be much safer in very different cars, maybe our human tastes have been terraformed to fulfill the avidity of some powerful lobby.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by rictic on Monday April 28, 2014 @12:24PM (#7660966)
Are there any studies that back up your claims that small cars would reduce the death toll? I follow the intuition, but China has over twice as many deaths per car on the road as the United States: (36 per 100k vs 15) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-re...

There are of course other factors going on than just the weight of the cars, e.g. traffic laws, enforcement, community norms around driving, ratio of scooters and motorcycles, car safety ratings, etc etc etc. but there are difficult tradeoffs here too. An egg-car will cause less damage in a low velocity impact with a pedestrian, but at highway speeds it will also do less to protect its passengers.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by jsmthrowaway on Monday April 28, 2014 @02:30PM (#7661947)
I actually don't follow the intuition. The thought of putting a smart fortwo into a barrier at speed terrifies me, whereas I've done it in a Toyota Camry (pedestrian on freeway over blind crest, nowhere to go), gotten out unharmed, and driven a rental to work the next day. Also if I hit a pedestrian at 25mph I don't think it matters which I'm driving.

The ads don't help. They show the car's frame holding up a pickup truck and so forth; yeah, that's great and all, but how about crumple zones?

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by Theodores on Monday April 28, 2014 @03:00PM (#7662136)
Crumple zones and needing a 'big car' is old fashioned safety.

Probably the best cars to study are the big brothers of the Smart Car - the Mercedes A and B series. The original A series had a problem with the elk test, that was fixed and is a side issue to the main safety advances.

The passenger cell is the key part, ideally you want the engine to go under it rather than land in the passengers laps. That is a key innovation for whether you can walk out afterwards.

Next is the steel the passenger cell is made of. It doesn't crumple, things bounce off it.

Then the real big innovations for survival are inside the passenger cell. Those airbags, the way the seat belt tensions, the way the steering column collapses. These are big things.

There is a 'Fifth Gear' episode on Youtube that you can watch to see how all of this works. They crash a big Volvo that happens to be a decade old and built when the crumple one was king into a modern Renault hatchback. In the hatchback the passenger compartment stays as is, all of the airbags go off, the crash test dummies walk off with not so much as a scratch. Even the doors open. Meanwhile, the Volvo is a scene of carnage. The firemen have to cut the crash test dummies out, leaving their amputated legs behind.

Personally I would want a full rally-car style roll cage inside whatever car I had if I had to have one, however, I gave up driving after crashing into an on-coming car :-) That was a turning point for me, I no longer derived pleasure from speed or sitting in traffic. I cycle now, or get the train. The accidents I am particularly keen to avoid are the rapid decelerations where, regardless of airbaggage, the brain crashes into the inside of one's skull to result in the same sort of complications Shumaker is having now (wish him well). His incident was skiing, not driving, but the same principle applies.

Speaking of F1, I would like to see a Google car do the new Electric Formula E series, lapping every driver on the grid like some mad Scalextric car, taking the most optimal lines through the bends and learning the track to go quicker and quicker... In F1 would be cool too, like an automotive version of IBM's chess playing adventures, taking on World Champions and just beating them hands down. That would be cool.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by altcognito on Monday April 28, 2014 @09:12PM (#7664258)
> Crumple zones and needing a 'big car' is old fashioned safety.

No. This is modern design. In the very cool Fifth Gear episode, you're seeing a car that is not designed with a good rigid passenger cell component (and also fails to transfer the energy of the crash around the passenger cell). Both cars have crumple zones. They are not all created equal.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crumple_zone

> A misconception about crumple zones sometimes voiced[citation needed] is that they reduce safety for the occupants of the vehicle by allowing the body to collapse, therefore risking crushing the occupants.

> Crumple zones work by managing crash energy, absorbing it within the outer parts of the vehicle, rather than being directly transmitted to the occupants, while also preventing intrusion into or deformation of the passenger cabin.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by brc on Monday April 28, 2014 @11:37PM (#7664795)
All modern cars have crumple zones - though smaller cars like the smart and A/B Class have very short crumple zones.

The difference in your video is the improvements in passenger safety cell construction - much of which comes down to higher strength steel being used in the passenger safety cell. Compare the size of the door pillars between a modern car and one from the 90s - in modern cars they are often twice as thick.

A modern volvo of the same size will fare even better than the renault.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by aembleton on Monday April 28, 2014 @06:47PM (#7663632)
Here's the Fith Gear video that you mentioned: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=emtLLvXrrFs
Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by bsder on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:31PM (#7663848)
A self-driving car doesn't need a steering column.

The steering column is one of the biggest problems to engineer around for impact safety.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by john_b on Monday April 28, 2014 @12:28PM (#7660994)
> "Since when do we need multi tons machine to move a being that is usually below 100kg from a to b"

You don't always need them. Short intra-city drives don't require a large vehicle. But most public transportation in the US is rather poor, so people buy a car that will cover their worst case usage: driving multiple people and their luggage between cities, possibly hundreds of miles. An electric egg car isn't safe or efficient for that.

There is a car lobby in the U.S. and it does have influence, but you have ignored Occam's Razor here. People buy large cars in the U.S. simply because they are useful. Creating competing services so large, individually owned cars are less useful is what projects like this and Uber are working on.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by gbog on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @12:06AM (#7664880)
> People buy large cars in the U.S. simply because they are useful.

You surely know that this cannot be true. In China, again, many rich people buy expensive luxury cars, and really have no need for them, except if you include "social status" in "needs".

I have a simple litmus test for detecting unneeded goods that people are trying to force into our minds: ads. We need normal food (neither fast nor organic), normal shoes (not Nikes), a door on our house with keys, etc. Except if it is very different in the US, I think no big ads campain are selling these.

However, each product that require a heavy handed ad campaigns is certainly lacking in desirability or usefulness. And it also means these industries are spending a lot of money selling you goods, instead of spending money making these goods better or cheaper.

Anyways, my bet is that the car industry is rotten to the bones, selling worldwide dangerous and superfluous multi-tons machines that could be replaced by many other, more useful, safe and scalable transportation means. And I hope Google and others will break this industry apart as soon as possible.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by gedrap on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @05:20AM (#7665843)
I am living in Beijing at the moment (Haidian), spent most of my life in Europe. I get what you mean and understand the efficiency of Chinese transport vehicles. But one huge thing you are missing is the cultural differences. They are pretty big.

>>>normal food (neither fast nor organic), normal shoes (not Nikes), a door on our house with keys, etc

I get what you mean. I spent a little time in the north-east Beijing villages and I know what you mean by minimality. But again, 'not normal' shoes will last longer. The house with a bit more than just doors will make you feel safer (or is just me a paranoid Westerner?).

Yes, there might be some lobbying and brain washing, as you call it. But as you can see, the culture is totally different. It's neither good nor bad. It's just the way it is.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by rthomas6 on Monday April 28, 2014 @10:33AM (#7660170)
I agree with you, but I think I can explain some of the rationale behind wanting big cars. Part of the reason is fear. "If I have a very small egg-car and everyone else has a heavy car, I'll be the one that is killed."
Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by munificent on Monday April 28, 2014 @12:16PM (#7660910)
> Part of the reason is fear. "If I have a very small egg-car and everyone else has a heavy car, I'll be the one that is killed."

That isn't fear, it's entirely rational behavior. This is one of those many cases where a group of people behaving individually in their self-interest results in a situation that's worse for all participants.

It would be better for everyone if we moved in aggregate to smaller, lighter cars, but no one can take that step unless we all do.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by mikeash on Monday April 28, 2014 @01:45PM (#7661622)
It's not a zero sum game. All else being equal, larger cars for everyone results in more safety for everyone.

Imagine two extremes. 1) You smack into another person at 70MPH while you're both in a cardboard box. Don't ask me how you got a cardboard box up to that speed, but you probably do not survive. 2) You manage to get a Maersk E class up to 70MPH and crash it into another Maersk E class. Assuming you're not at the front, you and the other guy probably both walk away from the crash unscathed.

Now, that doesn't mean that it's best for everyone to have huge cars. There are other factors beyond simply safety. Small cars can be much safer than large cars when designed and built well. My point is just that the shift to larger vehicles is not the sort of game-theoretic tragedy of the commons that one might imagine.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by shabble on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @06:35AM (#7666057)
> * Don't ask me how you got a cardboard box up to that speed, but you probably do not survive. 2) You manage to get a Maersk E class up to 70MPH and crash it into another Maersk E class*

I'd be more impressed if you got the Maersk up to 70mph, since it's 100k horsepower engines can manage less than half that.

And I suspect the collision would be pretty terrifying, given it would be dumping a kinetic energy load of 81GJ if I did the maths right (70mph ~= 31m/s, Emma Maersk ~= 170kton, E=1/2mv^2), which is somewhere around 20kton of TNT equiv.

The 300+ metre "crumple zone" might save you, but I wouldn't bet my life on it.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by mikeash on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @10:54AM (#7667361)
Also don't ask why I expressed wonder at a 70MPH cardboard box but not a 70MPH cargo ship....

Anyway, the kinetic energy involved in the ship collision would indeed be gigantic, but the mass available to absorb it is similarly gigantic. The energy will be going into the structure rather than into your fragile human body. It will take many seconds just to complete the collision. Compare this to the tiny fraction of a second available to decelerate the meatbags from 70MPH to 0MPH in a car collision at that speed.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by jaffeee on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @01:56PM (#7668781)
Larger cars dont result in more safety for anyone outside the vehicle.
Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by hackuser on Monday April 28, 2014 @04:39PM (#7662851)
A couple of counter-intuitive thoughts:

* The smaller car will stop and maneuver more quickly, avoiding more accidents.

* I read a study years ago that said the relative sizes and weights of vehicles did not significantly impact the outcomes for the humans inside. Instead, the relative positions of the 'hard-points' did (I forget the term, but the parts that don't crumple on impact). If you rear-end a truck and its rear hard-point goes through your windshield into your head (albeit a personal hard-point), that's bad news. If its hard-point hits your vehicle's hard-point then I imagine you mostly suffer from the sudden stop, at least in modern cars.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by rthomas6 on Monday April 28, 2014 @06:26PM (#7663525)
That is possible, but fear-motivated reasoning is rarely rational.
Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by mindslight on Monday April 28, 2014 @10:26AM (#7660119)
Don't get your hopes up, that brainwashing is still alive and well with the first word of Google's post being "Jaywalking".
Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by mc32 on Monday April 28, 2014 @12:30PM (#7661007)
Underscoring your sentiment is the origin of the term jaywalking http://paleofuture.gizmodo.com/the-invention-of-jaywalking-w...

Although, to be sure, with the speeds of modern vehicles, it makes sense that people's paths be predictable since vehicles are much less able to be nimble and swerve out of someone's path.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by mindslight on Monday April 28, 2014 @12:46PM (#7661110)
Predictability and not jumping in front of cars is unrelated to not being in a crosswalk. Crosswalks actually worsen these aspects, as they make drivers more prone to needlessly slamming on their brakes to wave people out while also fostering a sense of pedestrian entitlement instead of respectful temporal negotiation.

It's really not hard to look at traffic (all types), spot the existing gaps, and navigate within them. On some roads this is impractical due to traffic levels, but in most areas these type of roads are the exception.

(I suppose it's not surprising to be downvoted for saying this, as California has some of the worst drivers I've seen. It's rare that I am able to start walking and successfully pass behind a moving car, without having the driver needlessly stop while looking annoyed and acting like they're doing me a favor - even in parking lots! But frankly, anyone thinking of themselves as a hacker should surely understand and respect the value of down-to-earth informal negotiation and the peril of overformalized systems).

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by jhenkens on Monday April 28, 2014 @03:12PM (#7662196)
Perhaps it could be due to the fact that you are legally required to yield to pedestrians in a crosswalk? Not to say that people do yield often, but once a pedestrian is in a crosswalk, not yielding is a great way to get a quick ticket.
Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by mindslight on Monday April 28, 2014 @03:49PM (#7662468)
Yes of course that's what it's due to. But those laws are made for people who need/want traffic to stop so they can take their time, which is understandable. But when you're willing to wait three seconds on the curb for the one last car before a large gap, but you have to turn your entire body away and pretend to daydream just so that it won't needlessly stop, sensibilities have gone too far in the other direction.
Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by rahimnathwani on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @06:41AM (#7666080)
I agree with the sentiment (and you've seen how small and light my scooter is) but I can totally understand why people buy larger/stronger vehicles for safety. Unfortunately, it becomes an arms race: I'd feel perfectly safe in one of those egg cars if _everyone_ had one. As it is, though, I'd be really worried about driving one because I would be more vulnerable than in a traditional car, but much less able to take evasive action to avoid collisions (vs. my scooter).

Having said that, I'm writing this on the bus, which can take me to most places in Beijing if I'm not in a hurry.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by neolefty on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @06:26AM (#7666031)
Also in China, and presumably in much of the rest of the world, cars are expensive compared to average income.

Car use would open up to a new class of people who wouldn't need to own it.

Actually, that's already kind of the case -- in China (some parts anyway) it's easy to find a "black taxi" willing to carry your mattress across town when you move. Maybe because labor is cheap in China.

However, I have a hard time seeing automated driving working out in China's traffic. (Maybe I'm just unaware of the sate of the art!)

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by rahimnathwani on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @06:47AM (#7666100)
Beijing also has:

- inexpensive (relative to the West) taxis

- great taxi-hailing apps

- good private hire apps

(and Uber launched a limited service here last week, although I have yet to try it.)

Re: automated driving, the main roads here are pretty wide compared to those in European cities, so perhaps it wouldn't be so bad. I don't know how a computer would deal with a physical confrontation after a minor accident, though.

Re:The latest chapter for the self-driving car: mastering ci... by tomkarlo on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @01:37AM (#7665168)
Great and all (and I'm a big fan of smaller, lighter passenger cars) but it only works to a point - a tiny car might not kill a pedestrian or someone else in a tiny car, but it's unlikely to do well in an accident with a semi truck, or a large fixed barrier. (And people buy cars based on how well they protect the passengers, not others.) We should have smaller cars, but with reasonable safety features.