Re:X Could Learn a Lot from Vista, Windows 7
by derefr on Sunday August 16, 2009 @08:16AM
(#766001)
A comment—complaining about an article that complains about a specific X in Y, and compares it to a better X in Z—suggesting that the poster use Z instead of Y. (I have a theory that this template covers about 10% of IT-related blog post replies by weight.) I have to wonder, haven't you ever used something that's better in almost every way, but worse in one important one? You don't spend time writing a blog post about Y's failures unless you love Y, and want it to get better (or are getting paid by Z, but that's only applicable to very well-known bloggers.)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:X Could Learn a Lot from Vista, Windows 7
by apotheon on Monday August 17, 2009 @12:23PM
(#768428)
That's only relevant to the discussion at hand if the person in question actually seems to believe that Y is better than Z in all ways except one. Instead, he appears to believe that Z is better than Y in all ways, period, and uses Y just to have reasons to complain.