Your post seems mainly to be about income inequality, particularly pointing out that it's often transitory and different over lifetimes than in single years. Those are interesting points, but Piketty's book isn't about income inequality. The book is mainly about capital holdings and what they do in economies over time. With issues such as: returns on capital vs. labor; concentration of capital holdings; persistence of large capital holdings over time; ratios between economies' capital holdings and rates of income; etc.
Even looking only at the political part of the book (which is not the biggest part), his concern isn't about income inequality, or even inequality in general, but about wealth inequality that can maintain itself persistently. He predicts (with some caveats) that current trends suggest large holders of capital will increasingly be able to maintain and increase their capital holdings, producing stable multigenerational stocks of wealth akin to those seen in 18th and 19th century Europe. Whether right or wrong, that's not at all the same an issue as inquiring into things like income ratios between Google's programmers and janitors. He's interested in a more structural level about e.g. the differences between an economy where extant wealth equals 10 years of annual income, versus one where it equals 2 years of annual income (he argues that in the latter case existing wealth stocks are less entrenched, because they in effect represent fewer years "head start" over current income earners, and that this ratio explains some things about the relative roles of capital in 19th-century France vs. 19th-century U.S.).
My assumption was that income (flow / p&l) & wealth (stock / balance sheet) are correlated.
By pointing about churn in income & some of the causes of income inequality - we could have a different perspective on the wealth inequality question.
Also - the HBR review the article references talks about the income question:
Since the 1970s, though, the U.S. has seen a sharp and unparalleled increase in the percentage of income going to the top 1% and especially 0.1%.
Top 1%: $383,000 Top 5%: $188,000 Top 10%: $140,000 Top 25%: $89,125 Top 50%: $50,742 Top 75%: $25,411 Top 90%: $12,154
Give that those incomes are so low[2] it isn't surprising that the top percentiles have so many people that have at least one year in them. As an example, My mother, who reached $60k for 2 years at the end of her 45 year career had to take a 401(k) withdrawal[3], which is counted as income, which boosted her, barely, into the top 20 percent, for one year. It's pretty easy to see how people can be boosted into higher brackets for short periods of time. Picketty is talking about wealth, not income, so it's hard to see how you could build wealth consistently with short term boosts. Remember, 54% of people experienced poverty or near poverty as well...potentially wiping out any wealth they had accrued.
1: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2012/01/15/business/one-p...
2: I think we see incomes like $188k as low or middle class when they are anything but. Median household income is only ~$50k.
3: Please try to avoid doing this!
Your earlier comment about the income level brackets was fantastic!
That helped better understand the issue.
Not sure why your comment was downvoted!!
Th
A+ for politics, C- for attention to detail!
========================
1) Churn in Inequality:
========================
12 percent of the population will find themselves in the top 1 percent of the income distribution for at least one year
39 percent of Americans will spend a year in the top 5 percent of the income distribution
56 percent will find themselves in the top 10 percent
73 percent will spend a year in the top 20 percent
Although 12 percent of the population will experience a year in which they find themselves in the top 1 percent of the income distribution, a mere 0.6 percent will do so in 10 consecutive years
54 percent of Americans will experience poverty or near poverty at least once between the ages of 25 and 60
Half of those who earned over $1 million a year did so just once during this period (1999 and 2007), while only 6 percent reported millionaire status across all nine years
Data analyzed by the I.R.S. showed similar findings with respect to the top 400 taxpayers between 1992 and 2009. While 73 percent of people who made the list did so once during this period, only 2 percent of them were on the list for 10 or more years.
via: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/20/opinion/sunday/from-rags-t...
=========================================================
2) How much is the inequality being driven by Technology?
=========================================================
Sam Altman @YC: http://blog.samaltman.com/technology-and-wealth-inequality
Albert Wenger @ USV : http://continuations.com/post/52302452621/internet-and-incom...
=========================================================
3) How much of this technology led inequality is transistionary?
===========================================================
Innovation has brought great benefits to humanity. Nobody in their right mind would want to return to the world of handloom weavers. But the benefits of technological progress are unevenly distributed, especially in the early stages of each new wave, and it is up to governments to spread them. In the 19th century it took the threat of revolution to bring about progressive reforms. Today’s governments would do well to start making the changes needed before their people get angry.
Via: http://www.economist.com/node/21594298/print