- YouTube’s failed attempt at improving the comment section
- The new mobile YouTube app entirely covers the video with supersized play/pause button.
- The odd merge of touch and desktop UI elements in Windows 8
I think a huge factor for hate is also whether the re-design was preannounced. I think, ideally the user would have the option to upgrade the page, just as they can decide whether to upgrade their phone or not.
If so, these existing designs are really the best-of-the-bunch, beating out the competition, and perhaps this is because they are better on criteria that have been overlooked or not fully understood.
Now that Facebook, Google, Wikipedia have "won" the competitions in their original space, we might believe they are no longer under strong selective pressure of competitive evolution.
Facebook and Google might therefore be inclined towards major redesign which benefit them more for commercial reasons. This alienates some people, yes, but since the companies no longer have to fear immediate challenges from competitors, they can afford to provide users with a less optimised and more profitable design.
Wikipedia has no real motivation to change the design away from one which is known to be good: nobody strongly benefits from a major redesign.
But you made it, so you won't say that your own baby is ugly ever no matter how many people provide reasoned arguments
Rather, it seemed like they were doing a redesign for the hell of it. Out of some belief that if something hasn't changed in X time, it should. It tries to justify itself using itself.
We've been using the Harvard architecture for decades now. Should we change it? It's been some time, after all.
Think about radically updating some of these to see what I mean:
- Facebook Newsfeed
- HNs homepage
- Vim interface
- Google Search Page
- Craigslist homepage
- Your favorite web mail client
- Your favorite Smartphone main screen
- Reddit homepage
You can come up with the most amazing forward-thinking improvement, and somebody without a doubt will send you so much hate that you'll think it is that person's only goal to wipe out your family line.
This doesn't mean we shouldn't do it, it just means that we have to be aware of that section of the population and come up with a strategy that either does 1) a slow migration for the people with old mental model, 2) provides an alternative "classic" view, or 3) completely ignores that section of the population since they may represent a very small minority. I tend to go for 1,2,3 in that order, but of course this can vary differently depending on the project.
Nice job with the re-design by the way :)