Re:“Mostly functional” programming does not work
by Silhouette on Sunday April 27, 2014 @10:48AM
(#7655268)
Its not about beauty, its about buggy software.
Right. But until we have a comparable body of production software written in pure functional code -- and by comparable, I mean closer to the volume of code written in today's mainstream languages and by average developers, not a few applications written by elite developers -- we can't say for sure whether the pure functional approach does in fact prevent buggy software, or whether it simply leads to different kinds of bugs.
A lot of advocacy for functional programming and languages like Haskell makes claims about being safer because certain types of programmer error are prevented. However, relatively little commentary also highlights downsides like the need for accumulating parameters and strictness annotations just to achieve acceptable performance, or the maintenance hazards of having both monadic and non-monadic implementations of algorithms. Until someone finds a way to prove that a large-scale lazy functional program can't exceed the available system resources with an explosion of thunks, any claim that this approach is inherently safe seems rather premature.
Right. But until we have a comparable body of production software written in pure functional code -- and by comparable, I mean closer to the volume of code written in today's mainstream languages and by average developers, not a few applications written by elite developers -- we can't say for sure whether the pure functional approach does in fact prevent buggy software, or whether it simply leads to different kinds of bugs.
A lot of advocacy for functional programming and languages like Haskell makes claims about being safer because certain types of programmer error are prevented. However, relatively little commentary also highlights downsides like the need for accumulating parameters and strictness annotations just to achieve acceptable performance, or the maintenance hazards of having both monadic and non-monadic implementations of algorithms. Until someone finds a way to prove that a large-scale lazy functional program can't exceed the available system resources with an explosion of thunks, any claim that this approach is inherently safe seems rather premature.