News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The sharing economy has succeeded because the real econom... by 001sky on Saturday April 26, 2014 @04:24PM (#7652643)
Maybe, but you are the buyside. its not about you. its about the sell side, and why they bother. the thesis is that the cost of carry on the assets is too high (eg, expensive real-estate).

to make the sell side work, its a hassle. people overcome the hassle, because the need the money. and in turn, the sell to people like you who want to lose the hassle by not owning.

So, the sell side is long hassle-factor. The buy side is short hassle factor. One side has cash, and one side needs it. If the allocation in the last sentence was reversed, there would be a busted market. But since it's not--presto the market works.

Its a worthwhile bit of understanding. And its generally true in other eras. EG many large victorian homes in SF were too expensive to be single family homes, so they became flats in the 20th century. Same deal--the house is too valuable to carry as a single-use asset, so sub-divide it and capitalize to other peopel who didn't want the "hassle" of a massively expensive house. Basicaly the upkeep became a problem when servants became too expensive.

That kind of thing--ie, a form of economic infeasibility--is what people are facing. Then, as now, even in higher price points. And thus you see decent listings for nightly and weekedn rentals in good neighborhoods where rents have shot up and people who could have afforede a private space now have "temp roomates" or what not a couple times a month to net a couple hundred dollars.

Re:The sharing economy has succeeded because the real econom... by jowiar on Saturday April 26, 2014 @06:57PM (#7653071)
Roll back further in history though and the notion of "owning things" was an invention - it wasn't that people wanted to "own a horse" - it's that the entire notion of ownership was invented to determine who got to "ride a horse when they wanted it".

For me, I don't want "to own a house with a lawn". I want "a convenient piece of grass to throw a football around, sit outside and eat lunch, and walk my dog". I don't want "to own a car" - rather, I want "A few times a month, access to a vehicle within a few blocks of my apartment for a few hours".

I think we're saying the same thing here, but the "sharing economy", is, more than anything else, about using communication technology to create finer grained matching between supply and demand - about matching access to goods with people who want to use them, about providing an opportunity to turn time into money and money into time to the extent that one needs and desires.

Re:The sharing economy has succeeded because the real econom... by baddox on Sunday April 27, 2014 @05:02AM (#7654436)
I don't buy your model of property. Sure, the specifics of legal systems are invented, but the basic idea of property was not, or if you like, they were invented by evolution.

The basic idea of property is that you decide a resource is your property, then you mark it in such a way that other people see your claim. Territorial animals do this, and it works. Not perfectly (no human system is perfect either), but they work.

The evolution part is how society comes to recognize territory markers, and which claims it respect and which it rejects. For an animal, the signal could be pheromones. If another animal smells a marker, they will tend to avoid that territory, because they know the "owner" will fight to the death if necessary, and the territory itself is worth less than the risk of taking the fight. But presumably, if an animal goes rogue and marks a huge area as its territory, there is a limit to what that animal society will respect. And of course, if resources get tight, things will break down into violence (just like in human society).

Re:The sharing economy has succeeded because the real econom... by randomflavor on Saturday April 26, 2014 @10:46PM (#7653697)
this sounds utopian. but if you didn't need the money would you go thru the hassle of sharing your car or house? the only reason people do it is to recover money because they didn't make enough to cover their lifestyle. others make it a business, renting multiple apartments in walkups and sell on airbnb creating private mini hotels. i do not know one person that has a savings and or a decent salary that would let a stranger into their home, or drive a stranger to a destination because they just love to share what they have and participate. they do it because they are fucked or close to it.

the concept of the timeshare vacation rental is closer to reality of what you speak about. shared leases, mortgages, etc etc.

a startup that divides the credit potential of multiple people into a mortgage would be a real sharing, and be able to purchase into it for a time period.

i know i need to raise a family and need a 3 bedroom house for X time. Can I effectively purchase someones mortgage for 18 years at a premium on the base apr?

Re:The sharing economy has succeeded because the real econom... by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday April 27, 2014 @06:58AM (#7654646)
I'll provide a counter example: We are a Couchsurfing host because we have resources beyond out needs. Our house has four bedrooms, occupied by four rent paying tenants. We have couches and a single bed available in Northern Tasmania, if you're ever in the area look us up (email in profile). I have a well paid full time job, cash investments, as well as investments in precious metals and shares. I even pick up hitchhikers. If you're in to rock climbing, bicycle polo, music, camping, food (I'm a certified nutritionist), and building things (I'm a structural steel engineer and fabricator), we might even get along.
Re:The sharing economy has succeeded because the real econom... by coldtea on Sunday April 27, 2014 @10:06AM (#7655097)
Couchsurfing is about projecting an "open" lifestyle, travelling etc. And it's done either by young people (to meet and "know better" other people) or by stable/upper middle class people.

Sharing in the sense of TFA, for money, is not the same.

Re:The sharing economy has succeeded because the real econom... by rezistik on Saturday April 26, 2014 @11:56PM (#7653892)
I think he means more like Zipcar than some other sharing thing. Where you share from a corporation, it feels like sharing and is considered sharing but it's actually renting.
Re:The sharing economy has succeeded because the real econom... by ArkyBeagle on Saturday April 26, 2014 @05:45PM (#7652869)
At some point, you have to consider not living there. If you have a luxury zipcode but not the income to support it, that's your choice.

If you could build the Transporter from Star Trek, the entire real estate industry would gather en masse to have you and the invention erased such that you never existed.