News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by smacktoward on Friday April 25, 2014 @09:46AM (#7646375)
> They just said that they no longer consider social to be a separate unit, but now will be potentially integrated to everything they do. How is that the same thing as giving up on social?

A product that is everybody's second priority is nobody's first priority.

You can see how this plays out in practice by looking at this other bit from the TC article:

"One big change for Google+ is that there will no longer be a policy of 'required' Google+ integrations for Google products, something that has become de rigueur for most product updates."

Assuming this is true, it tells you everything you need to know about G+'s current position in the Google portfolio: it's been demoted from something strategic, something fundamental, to an optional add-on.

You can argue whether that's a good move or not (I think it is), but you can't really argue that it's not a step down. Because going from "this is part of what it means to be a Google product" to "this is something useful we'll let individual units decide whether to use or not" is definitely a step down.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by Pxtl on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:19AM (#7646590)
To me, the distinction depends on whether they allow non-plus social integration. That is, if I can leave comments on X and that comment exists outside of the Google Plus infrastructure? Then Plus is dead.

Otherwise? Plus is fine. That's the question. Is it "G+ is no longer mandatory" or is it "Commentary/messages can go outside of G+".

The former means G+ is alive and well. The latter means it's dead.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by Yhippa on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:26AM (#7646639)
How do you feel the same way about websites that require you to use Facebook, Disqus, or Livefyre to comment on the site? Do you choose not to participate if they require one of those?
Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by barrkel on Friday April 25, 2014 @12:04PM (#7647296)
I participate on Disqus, but only on economics and tech blogs. Effectively, I've compartmentalized my Disqus identity to a particular persona (not much different to my HN one).

I don't comment on any website using Facebook. Actually, I have FB completely blocked in my primary browser, so I never even see any assets served up by facebook.com or fbcdn.net etc. If there is a Facebook comment section, I don't see it.

It's a matter of identity and overlaps in facades.

In real life I behave differently in business meetings, in pub chats with coworkers and other people in the industry, at college friend meetups, at secondary school friend meetups, at family meetups. I'm effectively different people with different shared culture for all these people. Comments I make in one context will not translate, and in some cases may even offend, in one of the other contexts because it will rely on the culture shared with that group - especially when the culture was created when I was much younger.

This is why wider web Facebook identity is abhorrent to me, just as much or almost more so than Google+ unified identity. The straw that broke the back of Google+ for me was Youtube comments. When I couldn't leave a comment on a silly cat video without wondering if it was showing up to my business contacts, I deleted my Google+ profile so that I could break the link with my YT account. I couldn't find any other way to break the link, and Google+'s benefits, such as they are, weigh so little with me that I would, and have, give them up in a heartbeat in order to be able to make another pseudonymous comment on YT.

So the question to me is more subtle than non-mandatory Google+ integration meaning Google+ is dead. Non-integration of Google+ with YT is all positive, as far as I'm concerned. And more deeply, for people who live more of their lives online (rather than especially older relatives who mostly use the internet to keep in contact with family and close friends), the idea of a single unified identity for the internet is fundamentally a non-starter. So any move from Google to make it non-mandatory is actually the only workable way forward.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by Pxtl on Friday April 25, 2014 @01:00PM (#7647654)
Facebook I avoid, not because I don't trust or use Facebook but because I don't trust various facebook-based applications not to post spam in my feed.

But disqus? Absolutely, for the reason I outlined above. Disqus does what Google Plus should - a unified commenting infrastructure that is not opinionated about how comment threads should be run or identity or whatever.

Disqus has a lot of weaknesses, but they're mostly bugs and performance problems. Google should have made a Disqus and then bolted it onto their Facebook clone.

Instead, they made a Facebook clone and perverted it into a Disqus system.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by dewiz on Friday April 25, 2014 @11:31AM (#7647101)
Personally I interact only on web sites where I can register with my email address. The sites you listed are those that I avoid more, I don't like knowing my comments are tight to my personal identity on a service that does also manage content. ie. I would be ok using an OpenID from a company that does only OpenId. FB/Google/etc. authentication platform is just a way to build up their userbase to make money out of user profiles (which is not necessarily bad, but I don't want to be a product just because I need to post in a forum).
Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by danieldk on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:42AM (#7646762)
That is, if I can leave comments on X and that comment exists outside of the Google Plus infrastructure?

Or what about: if you can sync your LinkedIn and Facebook address books in GMail.

Microsoft's mail services offer that feature and it is very handy. I have always assumed that GMail doesn't, because Google wants to push Google+. In other words, Google+ is blocking progress in GMail.

Another such example is Hangouts. Hangouts in itself is quite good. However, you get a severely limited version of Hangouts if you do not have a Google+ profile. E.g. you cannot add photos to a conversation on Android without G+ or initiate group conversations. Again, Google+ is blocking progress Hangouts, which could be of great use in business, but most companies probably don't want to enable Google+ in their Google Apps.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by funkyy on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:54AM (#7646864)
IMO Google Plus can be defended only by its users. I always follow the rule - dont read reviews/reports by supporters of a product.

I know quite few users using it - but none of them is using it more than just few minutes a day and most of them use this as LinkedIn alternative rather than Facebook (something that Google+ should be from the very beginning). You cannot just copy Facebook, add few features and expect to score a success. From the very beginning the whole idea was wrong.

Google as an innovative company should either rethink whole social concept (without taking FB as an example but building social network from the ground with help of boutique analytics and design companies for more personal touch), or focus on mobile social networking as a player owning second largest mobile market in the web.

Its same as Linux users trying to explain everyone why Linux is better than Windows. It is - but not for average Joe, and thats the reason this OS will be marginal one for personal use. Nothing changes that, no statistics will prove otherwise even with such a strong fan base. TC was right - no reason to hate.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by mathattack on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:00AM (#7646473)
"One big change for Google+ is that there will no longer be a policy of 'required' Google+ integrations for Google products, something that has become de rigueur for most product updates."

This is huge. I wonder if there will be less pressure for people to use it similar to Facebook.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by garfij on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:21AM (#7646598)
You could also argue it's the difference between "dogmatic adherence" and "strategic application". At this point G+ is already integrated into all the major components of their platform. While I agree this is a good move, I don't necessarily see it as a step down. Requiring all new products to immediately integrate could be a major speed bump in development, so I can see how if G+ is not truly needed in the product, that it makes sense to allow for not requiring it.
Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by shadowmint on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:33AM (#7646706)
Well, since 'nothing is wrong! its fine! google+ all the things' has been the dogmatic adherance for the last what? 3 years? ... you have to acknowledge that at the very least this is an admission their previous practice was stupid and harmful.

...which is a good change.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by MattCruikshank on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:40AM (#7646745)
Is "security" your first priority, or is adding features your first priority? How about uptime? How about profitability?

Only one of those can be your first priority, so which is it?

I think Google+ is also one of their first priorities.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by Ensorceled on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:52AM (#7646840)
That's a silly argument and shows a complete misunderstanding, or at least naive view, of product development.

Security, uptime and profitability are all table stakes. Not priorities.

Google+ just went from table stakes to priority #2.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by MattCruikshank on Friday April 25, 2014 @11:26AM (#7647076)
Knowing who you are, knowing you you like to Follow, knowing who you like to share with, those are "table stakes," to use your term.

Google didn't know who you were, who you followed, who you shared with, and so Google+ looked a lot like a product to you.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by Ensorceled on Friday April 25, 2014 @12:46PM (#7647558)
I think you are too emotionally involved or don't play poker and missed the reference. If Google+ is now a feature that divisions can choose to integrate or not, it's not table stakes.

No silo of Google gets to choose whether to be secure or not or what level of scalability or whether they'll decide to be profitable or not.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by MattCruikshank on Friday April 25, 2014 @01:24PM (#7647818)
It's table stakes for a company to know how to do social integration.

Not all products that a company offers need social integration.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by RivieraKid on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:45AM (#7646788)
> I think Google+ is also one of their first priorities.

If they're smart, it's not. The aggregate value Google+ provides is negligable compared to their other services.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by MattCruikshank on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:50AM (#7646826)
I upload photos to Google. I want to chose who I share them with, that's Google+'s Circles.

I also upload videos, create documents, write blog posts, etc.

If I couldn't chose who I share those things with, I wouldn't be using those things.

The value G+ adds... makes those other services usable.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by RivieraKid on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:57AM (#7646892)
> The value G+ adds... makes those other services usable.

For you. The aggregate value Google+ provides is negligable compared to their other services, such as search, maps, email, YouTube, Chrome or Android.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by MattCruikshank on Friday April 25, 2014 @11:23AM (#7647049)
In Search, I see results I personally +1d. I also see blog posts from friends in my Circles.

In Maps, I see reviews of places written by my friends.

I rarely share YouTube videos publicly. Most of my videos are shared privately with Circles.

Google Play shows me reviews for Aps from people I've Circled. That affects my Android use.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by RivieraKid on Friday April 25, 2014 @12:16PM (#7647376)
I'm not arguing that G+ doesn't have value for you. I'm saying that it has negligable aggregate value compared to other Google products. That's why it shouldn't be a priority.

For example, I'd say that I use G+ more than 95% Google users and I wouldn't mind much if it disappeared.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by barrkel on Friday April 25, 2014 @12:07PM (#7647320)
I deleted my whole G+ account just so I could make an anonymous YT comment.

FWIW.