Netflix doesn't have a transit provider any more. They are piping directly into Comcast and wanted to do so for free. I want my website to be delivered to all Comcast customers for free, do you support that?
Shouldn't Comcast be required to purchase enough capacity to provide high-quality service to their residential customers? SFI between a content provider and an eyeball network should be a mutually beneficial cost reduction, but Comcast has enough market power (captive broadband subs) that they can get away with intentionally not buying enough capacity to serve their customers.
A peering agreement is free when both sides are accepting traffic for the others, but that's not what is happening in this case. Netflix -> Comcast is one way.
Still waiting for an answer to my previous question, should Comcast delivery my personal website to their customers for free?
But Netflix was using them for almost 100% of their traffic delivery. That's insane. There are other transit providers they could have paid more to and gotten better service, but that would have meant higher costs.
The whole irony of this situation is that I've heard rumors that Netflix is paying less per gigabit to Comcast than they paid Cogent while getting better service than they would get from a top-tier provider. If that's true, other companies will be lining up to get a similar deal because they'd just be cutting out the middlemen.
It seems like Comcast entered a shitty peering arrangement with Cogent and decided not to upgrade the interconnect links in retaliation. Netflix gets caught in the crossfire and ends up having to pay Comcast directly to avoid a few million angry customers. Is there any transit provider that Netflix could have gone with that has enough interconnects with the Comcast network? If not, Netflix is forced to pay whatever price Comcast names for their customers to receive adequate video streams.
> I want my website to be delivered to all Comcast customers for free, do you support that?
Sure, if your website has a peering arrangement with Comcast. Comcast isn't required to offer one to you, though.
This is not true. Netflix has to pay for transit of the bits leaving their servers just like everyone else. They just pay their transit provider for this, not Comcast (well, except when it is Comcast, but that's beside the point).
The right ways for Comcast to keep their costs under control re: video streaming would be to either meter pricing or drop rate limits. The problem is that metering is unpalatable to their customers, and rate limit drops would expose the lie that the entire cable modem marketing engine is based on (that last mile downstream throughput maximum is the only number that matters).