Re:The Case Against ISP Tolls
by mikeash on Thursday April 24, 2014 @05:11PM
(#7643029)
No, Comcast customers who use Netflix significantly increase those costs. It's not Netflix's doing.
If the usage pattern of Comcast's users is changing such that Comcast's internet offerings are no longer bringing in enough revenue to support usage, that's a problem with the offerings. They need to charge more, or charge differently.
However they change it (if indeed they need to change it, and it's not just a money grab, which seems more likely) then they need to charge based on how their users use the service, not what specifically they're using it for. If peak usage is a problem then charge more for peak usage, but there's no reason that A should pay more for the same peak usage as B just because A's peak usage involves Netflix.
If the usage pattern of Comcast's users is changing such that Comcast's internet offerings are no longer bringing in enough revenue to support usage, that's a problem with the offerings. They need to charge more, or charge differently.
However they change it (if indeed they need to change it, and it's not just a money grab, which seems more likely) then they need to charge based on how their users use the service, not what specifically they're using it for. If peak usage is a problem then charge more for peak usage, but there's no reason that A should pay more for the same peak usage as B just because A's peak usage involves Netflix.