Re:Ruby Security Have You Not
by molf on Thursday April 24, 2014 @02:43PM
(#7642090)
The graphs of Gem distribution and Vulnerability distribution are utter nonsense. You can't just measure your mean and standard deviation and expect a bell curve that fits those two parameters to correspond to your distribution. Especially if you cut off one of the tails.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Do you mind sharing how you would present this data?
Start with having a y-axis. That graph isn't a graph. It's just two numbers.
A histogram.
Why do you think it would be better/more meaningful?
The current graph is actively misleading because it misrepresents the data as following a (truncated) normal distribution when that's very unlikely to be the case. A histogram would show the actual distribution.
The kind of graph being used here -- a "best fit" bell curve based on the sample mean/s.d. -- can be useful when overlaid on a histogram, to illustrate how closely the data can be approximated by a normal distribution. Without that context, it's essentially meaningless.