News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by BrandonMarc on Thursday April 24, 2014 @02:19PM (#7641932)
Another ignorant question ... so you have a massively powerful microwave beam pointed at a certain spot of your nation. What happens when it misses? Passes over the inhabited land that's infinitesimal fractions of a degree away from the target?

From 36000 miles, a few miles is a rounding error. Must take some huge tolerances to keep the beam pointed in the right place.

Is this even dangerous, or am I off base? I know they're nervous about nuclear since Fukishima, but unless I'm mistaken there's similar risks with this option.

Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by lutusp on Thursday April 24, 2014 @02:42PM (#7642082)
> Is this even dangerous, or am I off base? I know they're nervous about nuclear since Fukishima, but unless I'm mistaken there's similar risks with this option.

No, not true. Don't confuse ionizing radiation as from Fukushima, with non-ionizing radiation, as from microwaves. They're very different. Microwave radiation isn't nearly as dangerous -- it can't break cellular bonds like ionizing radiation can, it can only heat things up.

A microwave power system would have to pass strict safety tests, to make sure the microwave radiation level at the surface (near occupied areas) is well below that from the other big electromagnetic emitter -- the sun. That should be an easy standard to meet.

Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by finnh on Thursday April 24, 2014 @03:09PM (#7642249)
The danger isn't from "overflow" radiation when the microwave beam is on target. The danger is when the microwave is off-target by a couple hundred feet (teensy fractions of a degree, considering the distances involved) and suddenly your concentrated 1GW beam is pointing at an apartment building.

That beam is WAY more powerful than the sun per unit area. If not, we'd just use the sun.

Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by lutusp on Thursday April 24, 2014 @05:13PM (#7643046)
> suddenly your concentrated 1GW beam is pointing at an apartment building.

Wait ... have you calculated the antenna size required to produce a beam able to pick out an apartment building, at microwave wavelengths, from orbital heights? Consider the distances and the available microwave frequencies, and you'll see that you cannot get a beam narrow enough to resolve an apartment building from orbital heights, with any reasonable dish size.

Remember that, at sufficient distances, all antennas become cosine emitters with no ability to concentrate their energy in a specific location. This is true for lasers, x-ray emitters and it's certainly true for microwave emitters.

My point is that a practical system such as we're discussing must have a large receiving array to accommodate the beam size at ground level. It's not going to be anything resembling a death ray.

Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by InclinedPlane on Thursday April 24, 2014 @07:36PM (#7643799)
"That beam is WAY more powerful than the sun per unit area. If not, we'd just use the sun."

A common misconception, but untrue.

What matters isn't power per area but cost per kilowatt-hour. To collect solar power on Earth you need a lot of expensive components (photovoltaic cells), plus you probably need to track the sun, and even so you'll have huge losses due to night-time, weather, winter sun angle, and so on. In comparison, a rectenna array is just a bunch of little bent pieces of wire. It's almost trivially inexpensive to build, and in some cases it can live side by side with other land uses. Even if the power density is only a few hundred watts m^2 (compared to over a kilowatt/m^2 from the sun at peak power) that power can be converted with upwards of 80% efficiency (compared to much less than 50% efficiency) and the full amount of that power is available 24/7 through every season. The hypothetical 1kw/m^2 at noon on a summer's day actually rounds out to only a tiny fraction of that over the entire year. Meanwhile, a rectenna converting 100 W/m^2 of RF power can end up producing the same average power as a solar installation, except that power is always available and the cost of the ground component is a teeny, tiny fraction of the ground solar installation.

That still leaves the cost of the space component, of course, which is decidedly non-trivial. But a big advantage is that the space component can have a very, very long service life and can also serve various markets (especially remote regions where power delivery is difficult) which can provide the up-front high-profit business to pay off its cost.

Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by finnh on Thursday April 24, 2014 @08:17PM (#7643971)
Thanks for the really informative post - i appreciate it.
Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by skorgu on Thursday April 24, 2014 @03:49PM (#7642527)
> That beam is WAY more powerful than the sun per unit area. If not, we'd just use the sun.

Not necessarily. Rectennas can get ~80% conversion efficiency, PV panels you can actually get in bulk are closer to 30. So you can have a beam about as strong as the sun and get ~triple the power out the other end by using microwaves instead of light.

Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by danielweber on Thursday April 24, 2014 @04:01PM (#7642618)
When you express what SPS is doing as "making solar 3 times more land-efficient" it looks kind of crazy. Maybe dump the billions of dollars that would be needed for launching just one of these into squeezing another percentage point out of all new solar cells.
Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by worldsayshi on Thursday April 24, 2014 @03:56PM (#7642579)
Just use multiple source satellites for each destination collector. Each being harmless, together they are powerful enough for a decent output.
Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by puls on Thursday April 24, 2014 @02:37PM (#7642045)
I can't believe nobody has mentioned this yet: exactly this was one of the standard disasters in SimCity 2000, where "microwave" was one of the power plant types.
Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by HCIdivision17 on Thursday April 24, 2014 @03:21PM (#7642327)
Thanks for saving me the trouble.

Microwave tech was awesome and cost effective until the first time the satellite got out of alignment and burned half the city down. I've been terrified of the idea ever since: you just can't make a weapon like that fail safe, and if you do manage, then your throughput is too low to make it worth it.

Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by worldsayshi on Thursday April 24, 2014 @03:53PM (#7642564)
What you possibly could do is to not have a single emitter but loads of them for each collector. So that a single satellite getting out of alignment would be harmless. Many emitters would need to get out of alignment pushing the beam in the same direction for it to be harmful.
Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by XaspR8d on Thursday April 24, 2014 @02:40PM (#7642067)
Total nostalgia anecdote here, but Sim City 2000 had that as a disaster. I believe it was a constant risk whenever you built orbital-solar-to-microwave plants.
Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by Someone on Thursday April 24, 2014 @03:08PM (#7642242)
Read the article. It's not massively powerful; the beam will deliver about a kW per square meter (that's a GW per square kilometer).
Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by scott_karana on Thursday April 24, 2014 @03:41PM (#7642469)
So... it's as powerful as an unshielded microwave oven.

Imagine the hideous health implications if a city block got cooked.

Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by e12e on Thursday April 24, 2014 @09:54PM (#7644318)
Is it? Most (old) ovens used to be rated at 1KW, but they certainly weren't 1 square meter, more like half a square foot. You can fit quite a few half-square "feet" in a square meter (roughly 3*6 -- so 1kw/sqm would be about 1/18 of a microwave oven?).
Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by scott_karana on Friday April 25, 2014 @12:54PM (#7647609)
True, thanks for correcting my math. I still think there could be negative health effects, but obviously they wouldn't be as pronounced. :)
Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by spiritplumber on Thursday April 24, 2014 @08:06PM (#7643929)
Rather than imagining it, play Sim City 2000 and see for yourself!
Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by trhway on Thursday April 24, 2014 @02:26PM (#7641981)
and a movie about villains hacking in and taking control of the beam. Steven Seagal has similar one ...
Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by InclinedPlane on Thursday April 24, 2014 @07:27PM (#7643773)
The trick is you don't let the microwave beam get very strong. If you keep it at a fraction of solar power (say, a few hundred watts per m^2) then it won't be that dangerous. And yet because it's RF energy instead of solar energy and consistently at the same power 24/7 it's much, much easier to build the ground based infrastructure to collect and use the power.

Also, it's pretty easy to keep the beam away from populated areas.

Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by danielweber on Thursday April 24, 2014 @03:48PM (#7642524)
In fact, the beam wouldn’t even be intense enough to heat your coffee. In the center of the beam in a commercial SPS system, the power density would be 1 kilowatt per square meter, which is about equal to the intensity of sunlight

Of course, if it's only as intense as sunlight, you would wonder why they are bothering building a rectenna and an SPS. . .

Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by neolefty on Thursday April 24, 2014 @08:28PM (#7644008)
Seems simple to prevent: Keep an active signal loop between receiver and satellite. If something goes wrong, shut off the satellite. Worst case a couple of seconds, which with microwaves isn't long enough to do substantial damage (I suspect).
Re:How Japan Plans to Build an Orbital Solar Farm by Florin_Andrei on Thursday April 24, 2014 @03:27PM (#7642380)
This is probably the one thing that makes me act like a luddite - smash the darn thing before it gets a chance to even twitch a little.