Yes, assuming the employer considering actual output when they talk about "value" and not "seat time". Otherwise the next conversation is:
"Good for him, I'm starting at B co. in two weeks."
Also one of the most reliable ways to get better positions & pay appears to change jobs, suggesting your scenario is just a carrot on a stick that rarely happens in practice.
No one. Ever. And that group numbers in the hundreds. The hypothetical scenario is completely bogus.
I've never worked anywhere that promotions were just not given. And I'm including retail/fast food jobs from high school!
The companies where you can work your way up from entry level to executive are disappearing. The only one I am actually aware of that still promotes from within, even up to the top levels, is Publix.
So this conversation of yours would probably end in an investigation from the labor office to check whether John didn't cross the limits and was compensated fairly for the overtime.
> "We need you to work this weekend"
> "No thanks, see you Monday"
> Is perfectly reasonable.
This is likely to lead to another conversation later in the year:
"Why did John get the promotion I was up for?"
"He provided more value to the company by working those two weekends when we were delivering to our most valuable customer."
Do you consider that reasonable as well?