News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Quest to Build the Ultimate Music Player by baddox on Wednesday April 23, 2014 @04:52PM (#7636803)
You've failed to consider the way that digital audio works. If you have a 16 bit audio file, each sample can take on 2^16 values. If you reduce the volume in software, then each sample of the audio stream can take on fewer than 2^16 values. In the extreme case, you could reduce the volume in software so much that each sample can only take on a tiny number of values, in which case the audio will probably be unrecognizable.
Re:My Quest to Build the Ultimate Music Player by ubercow13 on Friday April 25, 2014 @02:16AM (#7644989)
Yes I'm well aware of that but that isn't what dynamic range is referring to in the above. The only thing you affect by reducing the volume in a digital signal is increasing the noise floor, or decreasing the signal-to-noise ratio. 16-bit audio already has a noise floor well below what a human can hear for a recording which has a "normal" volume as you might find on any CD. On top of this, when you use replaygain in your audio player, the digital volume adjustment is applied to a 24bit signal, and Windows (or whatever OS) has a 24bit or 32bit float signal path, and then most or all DACs are 24bit (for example newish Realtek integrated audio). So it really makes no difference to effective SNR either.