News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ada Initiative No Longer Partnering with GitHub by pyre on Wednesday April 23, 2014 @04:49PM (#7636787)
> the claim is that legal action will be taken only if the accusations are false

If someone wants to deny an accusation that is true, they will claim that said accusation is false. Claiming that legal action will only be taken if the accusation is false doesn't matter. Take this hypothetical:

  If the accusations against TPW are true, but he doesn't want
  the world-at-large to believe him. He will present to the
  world that the accusations are false. Claims that legal
  action will only be taken in the case that accusations are
  false don't mean that the accusations must be false for legal
  action to be taken.

  TPW could take legal action if he wants to present to the world
  that the accusations are false and smear the accuser. This would
  be a situation where the accusations are true, but legal action
  is still taken.
Re:Ada Initiative No Longer Partnering with GitHub by baddox on Wednesday April 23, 2014 @06:27PM (#7637332)
But the logical conclusion of your argument is that no individual or organization should ever threaten or take legal action against people who make false accusations.
Re:Ada Initiative No Longer Partnering with GitHub by pyre on Wednesday April 23, 2014 @07:14PM (#7637540)
I wasn't making an argument so much as stating that making only truthful statements does not indemnify one from being the target of legal action by someone that publicly states they will only go after 'false accusers.'
Re:Ada Initiative No Longer Partnering with GitHub by baddox on Thursday April 24, 2014 @04:33AM (#7639005)
That's true, but not particularly meaningful, since any statement from any person or company could be a lie regardless of how specific it is.

The company's claim that they will pursue legal action against false accusations should not discourage people from making true accusations, because the statement provides absolutely no information about what the company intends to do with true accusations. An analogy would be the statement "we will pursue legal action against anyone who trespasses on company property." That shouldn't discourage employees from going into their offices.