http://donpmitchell.wordpress.com/2010/02/25/heavy-interplan...
Absolutely no convincing long term value, but we just have to do it, just because we can. No asteroids to mine, no Mars bases to build, but "what happens if we go over there and look"
Gets my vote.
NASA clearly needs an intermediate step between LEO and putting a man on Mars. Venus flyby plus teleoperated rovers is the easiest mission I can think of that might also be useful.
We are never going to get outside the solar system in any meaningful way unless physics changes a lot, so any exploration of our backyard will be valuable.
I just think any attempt beyond the traditional approach will benefit the soul of the human race, as much as it will give us Teflon.
I'd agree with the both of you on the value of big space exploration projects as driving our culture.
I've wondered if a modern day manned flyby mission might make sense. A rover could be landed on Venus more easily than on Mars, but it would, by necessity, have a very short lifetime on the surface. Once it's out of coolant, the mission is over. So if you were going to land a rover (or rovers) on the surface of Venus, you'd need to maximize their effectiveness. One way to do this would be to teleoperate them in near real-time, which could be done if rover landing were coordinated with a manned flyby.
A manned flyby of Venus would be substantially cheaper and less risky than a manned mission to Mars. There's no manned landing component, and the flyby mission itself would take a little over a year, which is pushing the limit for human exposure to micogravity, but within the range that we have actual experience.
This kind of mission will, of course, only make sense if you are an advocate of manned space exploration in the first place.