Re:My Quest to Build the Ultimate Music Player
by mattgreenrocks on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @02:18PM
(#7629368)
I posit that the "just work on X," where X is the dominant player does not contribute anything to the discussion. Why can't we trust people to have investigated this possibility ahead of time?
Given the author's level of gumption, I'm glad he's not hacking on Rhythmbox. Rhythmbox is probably my favorite music player, but it's good to shake things up.
Re:My Quest to Build the Ultimate Music Player
by Edmond on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @02:24PM
(#7629416)
He's certainly within his right to work on whatever he wants. From an effort vs impact perspective however, it is usually better to build on something than reinvent.
In fact I would say this is major drawback on the Linux platform where there's a lot of duplication of effort that ends in half-baked solutions.
In any case, I merely asked; as I said the OP is free to pursue his interest as he sees fit.
Re:My Quest to Build the Ultimate Music Player
by zenbowman on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @02:21PM
(#7629391)
The number one reason is that you learn more when you experiment and try doing it on your own.
Same reason Ritchie and Thompson didn't continue to try to improve MULTICS.
Re:My Quest to Build the Ultimate Music Player
by mbrock on Wednesday April 23, 2014 @04:24AM
(#7632808)
Well, you learn more about some things and less about some other things.
Re:My Quest to Build the Ultimate Music Player
by ProAm on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @02:27PM
(#7629431)
Exactly. You learn more by doing.
Re:My Quest to Build the Ultimate Music Player
by jablan on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @04:20PM
(#7630159)
Can you install rhythmbox on a Pi without pulling whole GUI circus with it? OP already said he had started hacking on MPD (which IMO is much more suitable as a starting point than Rhythmbox), and gave up for really good and well elaborated reasons.
I built a python plugin with a web and android interface a few years back: http://code.google.com/p/rhythmote/
Still serves my needs excellently.