News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by pcmonk on Monday April 21, 2014 @10:05PM (#7625356)
For much art, the beauty is in the skillful use of a medium to say something that one wouldn't have expected to be able to say in that medium. Art is all about limitations. Photorealistic paintings are impressive because they aren't photographs. A well-written poem may be beautiful because it conjures up vivid images in the mind. In my opinion, text adventures can have a certain beauty because they tell a story in simple words (for a great example, see Photopia).

Of course, good art uses the limitations to its advantage. Most paintings aren't photorealistic because they're not trying to be photos -- they're trying to say something through their limitations. A good book or a good text adventure allows each reader to create their own images in their mind.

So, is there 'cheating' in art? Of course not. It's simply a change of medium. If you want to cross photographs with painting, go right ahead. That's a new medium, capable of saying new things. Don't pretend it's the old medium, and don't try to compare it directly to works in the old medium. But also don't dismiss it as 'cheating'. Take everything for what it is, not for how it compares to what you were expecting.

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by mistercow on Monday April 21, 2014 @10:32PM (#7625431)
>Photorealistic paintings are impressive because they aren't photographs.

I think this is the fundamental difference of opinion between people who think you can "cheat" in art, and people who don't.

I would argue that judging the quality of art based on the difficulty of producing it betrays a shallow appreciation of art. A person who says that is basically saying "I have no basis on which to judge this other than whether or not I could have produced it myself."

This is why you'll see a lot of overlap between people who sneer at "cheating" and people who dismiss things like modern art and found art as "not art".

In other words, the two groups are essentially using different definitions for the word "art".

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by vacri on Monday April 21, 2014 @10:49PM (#7625488)
The definition of 'art' is always fun, because there's a corner case for everything. To date, the most robust definition I've seen in those debates are "does someone call it art? Then it's art". Not necessarily good or insightful art, but art nevertheless.

And if you use that definition, you can't 'cheat' at art.

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by sirsar on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @12:16AM (#7625770)
In this area I find the writings of Eliezer Yudkowsky particularly insightful. Definitions are what he calls "disguised queries." When someone says "atheism is a religion" or "that's not art," they're trying to use the definition to make another statement - that atheists rely on faith, or that the work is not worthy of praise, display, etc.

The problem is that set membership isn't always binary, and not all members of a set share all the same characteristics. Just because something isn't difficult technically, doesn't mean it's not art. More importantly, if you're using "not art" to mean "not difficult technically," then saying "this isn't difficult technically, so it's not art" isn't a worthwhile statement. It's the disguised implications of the word "art" which make such statements so contentious. To paraphrase Eliezer, the argument about what is and isn't art is really a dispute over whether to infer art-related qualities of the work, like fitness for a museum. A dictionary is of no use here.

http://lesswrong.com/lw/nm/disguised_queries/

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by JoshTriplett on Monday April 21, 2014 @11:16PM (#7625576)
> To date, the most robust definition I've seen in those debates are "does someone call it art? Then it's art".

Agreed. I've seen debates over whether various forms of "abstract" paintings are art, but that's not a particularly interesting debate. Of course they're art; the simpler and more useful question is whether they're good art.

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by Crito on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @12:30PM (#7628631)
> "To date, the most robust definition I've seen in those debates are "does someone call it art? Then it's art". Not necessarily good or insightful art, but art nevertheless."

I am not satisfied with this definition.

Suppose we have 4 bricklayers constructing a wall. The four have worked together for a long time, and are very professional; they are capable of creating a uniform wall despite the wall being the product of their combined effort.

One of the four bricklayers claims that brickwork is art, having been artfully laid by a skilled craftsman. The other three bricklayers make no such claims about their work.

Is the wall art? Are only portions of the wall art? Can we distinguish the disjoint segments of the wall that are art and those that are not? If the artful bricklayer claims that the work of his colleagues is art, does it become art? What if they insist that it is not?

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by lutusp on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @12:42PM (#7628706)
> Is the wall art? Are only portions of the wall art? Can we distinguish the disjoint segments of the wall that are art and those that are not? If the artful bricklayer claims that the work of his colleagues is art, does it become art? What if they insist that it is not?

You've stated the problem (that our definitions of art are too vague), but to take this to the next level, we would have to define art, and get everyone to agree. That's a bigger problem than the one we face now.

> I am not satisfied with this definition.

To move beyond rhetoric, you would have to propose a definition that everyone would agree on. In the meantime, art is in the eye of the beholder.

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @12:34PM (#7628662)
Something is or is not art to the extent that people experience it as art, independently of what else it might be or the intention or skill of the creator.
Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by mc32 on Monday April 21, 2014 @11:17PM (#7625580)
>"does someone call it art? Then it's art"

I think that's the easy answer... but if you went to the curator of the art institute of Chicago, of the MoMA, or any other art institute of renown, they would have more strict interpretations of what's art, I would think.

That is there is "Art" and there is "art".

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by vacri on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @12:26AM (#7625796)
At MoMA I saw an unadorned bit of red paper, and in a separate piece, an unadorned bit of white card, both of which were mounted on the wall and presented as art. I personally think that's utterly crap art, bereft of any insight or skill... but it was still there, on the wall of a famous museum.

I may have mixed up the white card with a black one - but I do remember in travelling up the US east coast seeing three unaltered bits of paper in art museums, one white, one red, one black, with two of them in MoMA. I vaguely recall the red one having a thin, simple frame.

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by TheZenPsycho on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @01:12AM (#7625938)
What was the date on them?

The thing to keep in mind with stuff like that is usually it is not a straightforward case of they have trolled you and the museum as you may naively think.

If something is a blank red sheet of paper in a frame, perhaps dated from the early to mid 1960's they are likely referencing Kazemir Malevich, and making a joke about it perhaps along the lines of "I wonder how far I can take this minimalism thing and have people still call it art".

Once you can notice this, the cultural reference and context itself become the art- not necessarily the physical object, which, devoid of such historical or cultural context, is indeed just a blank fucking sheet of paper.

You may as well criticize Doge because you don't get why it's funny.

It's not funny, but you can still understand its context in internet cultural history. In 30 years you will remember doge as some significant cultural event, and contemporary artefacts will acquire value for being related to the event.

None of it is funny or good. but you remember it for its cultural significance.

A blank sheet of paper from the 1960's in a museum needs a little bit more help.

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by vacri on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @04:53AM (#7626491)
I can't recall the date. I fully understand that it's "How much can I get away with and still call it art" and I think that's crap art. Nevertheless, the point is that a curator at MoMA took in two of these and called it art, which is a counterpoint to the comment I was replying to.

Context is a weird thing with art. I remember an unsigned landscape painting that had experts split on whether it was done by $famous_artist or his student (I can't recall the artist). If it was $famous_artist, the painting was worth $200k, if the student, it was worth $2k. Independent of the merits of the specific painting itself, the name of the painter was worth 99% of the value. I get why that is, I just think it's a bit funny.

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by TheZenPsycho on Monday April 21, 2014 @11:25PM (#7625614)
having worked with some curators at similarly large (though not necessarily quite as well known) galleries, I'm pretty sure they use the

>"does someone call it art? Then it's art"

definition and have a poor opinion of anyone that attempts to be any stricter than that.

This comes from a painful history of curators dismissing lots of "modern" art in the 1960's, and thus missing out on lots of extremely lucrative investment opportunities.

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by mc32 on Monday April 21, 2014 @11:51PM (#7625702)
Perhaps...

But you're talking more about what becomes avant guarde and that's established by trendsetters. Sometimes that's people with money (maybe most of the time) --and curators race to tap that new trend. Sometimes there is little objective reason why something is "in" in art vs. something else. Remember the demand from Japanese patrons who had money before their bubble burst? And the artists raced to fill that demand and then the art dealers had no use for that art. So, some mediocre art can become important and the next day be forgotten. Curators, artists, galleries all are tuned into their patrons and their money. That's what sets trends and defines what's art.

There are few cases where that's not true --like the New Topographics: Photographs of a Man-Altered Landscape exhibit. But that's the exception, I think.

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by TheZenPsycho on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @12:18AM (#7625773)
perhaps, but none of that really contradicts what I said. Just that there's little use for any kind of objective classification system for "art" and "not art" to a curator. Just a fuzzy wuzzy wibbly wobbly sense of what is culturally significant, valued, and/or a "good investment".

None of which has much to do with what you might think of as reasoning about "is" and "is not". The question is never asked. There's no point to it. No value in the asking. That's an "art critic's" job. not a Curator's job.

And even in Art Criticism, since the dawn of "Post Modernism" there's been an implicit almost non verbal agreement to never ever question the "Art"-ness of something. It's never about whether it is or is not. Only what an artist is attempting to say, or what you are able to grasp from a work. To question the is-ness is boring and pedestrian, and marks you immediately as someone who is not really clued in.

Questioning whether something is art or "Art" with a capital A is kind of equivalent to an ad hominem. It has nothing to do with anything. It's name calling. It's not taking the argument or the artwork for what it is.

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by lambda on Monday April 21, 2014 @10:18PM (#7625393)

  In my opinion, text adventures can have a certain beauty 
  because they tell a story in simple words (for a great 
  example, see Photopia).
I never managed to get the appeal of Photopia. It just grated on me. Never could get the hang of Adam Cadre's style; always preferred Emily Short or Andrew Plotkin.
Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by pcmonk on Monday April 21, 2014 @10:24PM (#7625413)
When I discovered it, I hadn't done much interactive fiction for a while, and for some reasons it really got to me. I had no idea what to expect going in, and the experience of exploring it, even if it's essentially non-interactive, was enlightening. I loved when it occurred to me to type "fly". It was liberating. Like all good art, the experience it gave me is essentially incommunicable.
Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by JoshTriplett on Monday April 21, 2014 @11:14PM (#7625568)
> always preferred Emily Short or Andrew Plotkin.

Likewise, as well as Nick Montfort; Ad Verbum is exceptional.

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by moron4hire on Monday April 21, 2014 @10:46PM (#7625481)
I think you're missing the point of the story. Even the "old masters" used construction aids of some kind. It wasn't all free-hand on canvas. Often, nowhere near. Using a camera obscura or other such device is how you make photorealistic paintings.
Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by NAFV_P on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @09:01AM (#7627348)
> Using a camera obscura or other such device is how you make photorealistic paintings.

Photorealism refers to a specific period and set of artists, post Pop-Art. They used photographs very extensively, Richard Estes is one of the better known ones.

http://sayforward.com/ext/images/bus-reflections-flatiron-bu...

Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by cturner on Monday April 21, 2014 @10:52PM (#7625501)

    Art is all about limitations
Great philosophy. Maybe the digital revolution will foster a reaction against perfect industry, and we'll see an emphasis on doing confined things, for their own sake.
Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by moron4hire on Monday April 21, 2014 @11:09PM (#7625550)
That has always and will continue to always go on. The nature of it is such that it won't ever be mainstream. But if you know where to look, it's out there. Carpenters who use hand tools. Photographers who mix their own collodion. Musicians who build their own instruments. It's out there.
Re:There is no such thing as 'cheating' in art by bjterry on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @01:35AM (#7626006)
I agree with your premise that art comes from your medium and limitations, but wanted to elaborate a bit on a part that you and him are not explicit about (although I suspect you may feel similarly based on "Don't pretend it's the old medium").

The value of art is inextricably linked with the process used to create it. People will have a very different emotional reaction to a painting which is created by hand than a painting which is programmed into a computer and painted by a painting machine (this generalizes all sorts of ways, this is just an example). His examples were specifically of people who were deceptive about the process they used, first in the camera obscura, second in Frank Frazetta.

Of course, the term "art" is so imprecise that you can essentially import anything you want into it, including, if you so choose, the notion that part of the art is the practice of deceiving patrons about the way it's created in order to enrich yourself. I will allow that you can be an artist and lie about your methods to make your art more emotionally impactful, but I will not allow that doing so is the right thing to do or makes you a good person deserving of praise.

If I'm creating art by painting by hand on tiny grains of sand and the world becomes enamored with it, but it turns out I'm actually using a computer-driven process to paint them (in order to become rich and not to later reveal my actions as some sort of castigation of modern art or some other such thing; basically, take a charitable view of my example here), I think one of the following is the case no matter what your definition of art: 1. It's still art, but it's not art in the way I'm trying to suggest that it is, or 2. It's a performance art where the deception is part of the art, but I'm still a bad person for doing it.

Now, I'm not certain that the author would disagree with me (or that you would agree with me), because he doesn't directly address it in these terms. But he does say "I don't care how it's created: I only care about the results." and he also says that Frank Frazetta lying about how he created his art "does not diminish Frank Frazetta's art in the slightest." Perhaps he's saying that the art is still good taking into account the methods which he knows of and keeping mum on Frank Frazetta's deception. Maybe he doesn't think very thoroughly about ethics and so he's inconsistent, or maybe he has a system of ethics where deceiving people in this instance is okay.

Of course, presumably many artists are not specific about their methodology, or they could say that they want it judged by the results, not the methods, in which case I agree with the author that it should be judged as it is as an artifact. But I reserve the right to change my emotional reaction to the piece if I later learn that their method is to hire 10,000 third world artists to paint as well as they can and they select the best to portray as the result of their artistic process.