News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by spingsprong on Monday April 21, 2014 @12:05AM (#7619724)
I what some people here seemed to be missing, is this correlation isn't just lead was removed from the environment and 23 years later crime went down. It's that various areas has differing degrees of lead pollution and started reducing it at different times.

The places that reduced lead pollution first, saw the drop in crime first, the places that reduced it later saw the drop later. The eras that initially had high levels of lead had a larger drop in crime than areas that always had a low level.

And it's not just the USA either. The pattern holds pretty accurately for various nations around the world, like in Europe. Those who banned leaded fuel first, saw the drop in crime first, those who banned later, saw the drop later.

And these nations had massively differing crime policies. Some nations increased prison sentences to try and deter crime, and crime went down. Some nations put a huge effort into reforming criminals, and crime went down. And some nations cut prison sentence, and crime went down.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by mixmax on Monday April 21, 2014 @05:22AM (#7620369)
If the theory is true it could also account for the fact that violent crime is more abundant per capita in urban areas compared to rural areas since lead from gasoline will obviously be more abundant in cities with lots of cars per square mile compared to rural areas with very few cars.

Here's a link (2 minutes of googling..) showing the difference. http://www.victimsofcrime.org/library/crime-information-and-...

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by Timmmmmm on Monday April 21, 2014 @05:56AM (#7620435)
Yeah pretty sure that's because of other more obvious factors:

* Greater anonymity in cities * Higher population density * Juxtaposition of poverty and wealth

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by mixmax on Monday April 21, 2014 @06:14AM (#7620465)
Are these factors so obvious?

As an example poverty is most prevalent in rural areas according to this study: https://www.google.dk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd...

Be careful of citing "obvious", it can be deceiving.

Note that I'm not arguing that lead in gasoline proves a definite link between crime in rural vs. urban areas, just noting that there is the same correlation as stated in the article. I merely thought it was interesting, and that it might be the same effect at work due to the dilution of lead in rural areas because there are fewer cars.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by jpatokal on Monday April 21, 2014 @06:56AM (#7620548)
Juxtaposition of poverty and wealth, not poverty itself. In most American cities somebody from a poor neighborhood can walk a few blocks and mug a rich person at knifepoint, whereas in the average poor rural area, there aren't really any rich people around to rob.
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by Mvandenbergh on Monday April 21, 2014 @07:44AM (#7620650)
That's true but the vast majority of urban crime is poor on poor and takes place in the neighborhood where the victim and perpetrator both live.
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by mixmax on Monday April 21, 2014 @07:11AM (#7620586)
this is at best an anecdotal point, and seems more like something you just thought up. Is there any substance to this? Is crime in urban areas more prevalent because it is a shorter distance to walk for a potential mugger to get to a rich person he can mug?

This just doesn't seem very likely to me, but if you can back it up by numbers I'll gladly change my view.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by lutusp on Monday April 21, 2014 @12:58PM (#7622078)
> Is crime in urban areas more prevalent because it is a shorter distance to walk for a potential mugger to get to a rich person he can mug?

This is just a correlation, possibly meaningless, but an explanation for the decline in New York City crime over the last 30 years is that poor people can't afford to live there any more. It's just an opinion, true for most such views.

> ... but if you can back it up by numbers I'll gladly change my view.

Now that would be very difficult, even with the numbers. The number of poor people living in NYC is available, and the number of poor-on-rich crimes is available (both in sharp decline), but proving a connection between them is nigh impossible.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by astrodust on Monday April 21, 2014 @12:49PM (#7622008)
Why would that automatically lead to an increase in crime?

If you have wealthy areas, you have opportunities for less affluent people to get ahead through legitimate means. They have economic opportunities.

On the other hand an area that's entirely depressed is often infested with crime because there's no alternative to theft. The economic opportunities do not exist.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by ap22213 on Monday April 21, 2014 @08:28AM (#7620746)
Higher population density seems obvious. Increasing density increases the opportunities for violence.

But, since violence is more often directed at people that are known, rather than strangers, I find the other two suspect.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by logfromblammo on Monday April 21, 2014 @10:46AM (#7621268)
You can be as sure as you like.

The fact remains that the concentration of lead in the living environment is the most strongly correlated measurable datum to crime rate than any other single factor.

If you compare factors directly relating to motives, methods, and opportunities (the crime triangle) in different cities, the correlations are still weaker than whether the population was exposed to lead pollution as children.

This is not the first article on this topic that has been published. None of them, as far as I am aware, have proven causation rather than correlation--probably because proving it would take 20+ years and be grossly unethical.

But nevertheless, it would be interesting to see what happens if one city decided to completely eradicate lead contamination from within its limits, and compare it against cities of similar character that chose not to do so over the next 30 years.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by stevvooe on Monday April 21, 2014 @01:00PM (#7622096)
Not disagreeing outright, but there are studies[1] that link high-poverty areas with higher lead concentrations. There was also an interactive map, some time ago, that showed lead soil levels by zip code and they definitely seemed to match up with more problematic neighborhoods. Clearly, the factors you call out have an influence, but lead seems to be a part of that equation.

[1]: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22752852

Edit: switched low with high.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by jrochkind1 on Monday April 21, 2014 @01:06PM (#7622148)
(you mean high poverty areas correlated with lead concentration, right?)

My first guess would not be that lead causes poverty (is that what you are suggesting?), but that lead-producing activities (highways, factories, waste dumps) tend to be undesirable, and tend to be placed in poorer neighborhoods because poor people have less political power.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by stevvooe on Monday April 21, 2014 @01:19PM (#7622255)
Yes, I do mean areas with high poverty areas or low income.

I am not really suggesting any particular cause of poverty, but lead-soil levels seem to have some negative effect. The more important suggestion is that its not just income disparity, anonymity and juxtaposition of poverty and wealth, if at all, that leads to higher crime rates in cities.

In fact, mixed-income neighborhoods have been linked to better social mobility, but that is getting off-topic.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by jrochkind1 on Monday April 21, 2014 @02:15PM (#7622630)
I guess it's topical if it's about proper conclusions from statistics.

I think your conclusion, from correlation between lead concentration in soils to conclusiong "lead-soil levels seem to have some negative effect" -- is entirely unjustified.

The alternate hypothesis I mentioned seems as, or more, plasuble. That it's not lead-soil levels that are having any effect at all, but rather that lead-producing activities are socially undesirable, and end up in poor neighborhoods because poor people lack political power.

I suppose the scientific method would be to devise an experiment or investigation that would attempt to distinguish between these two hypothesis. Possibly people already have, and arguing about it in the academic literature now.

One danger of concluding causation from correlation in the 'big data' era is how easy it is to go hunting for correlations. If I test ketchup consumption against 1000 other variables, it may be fairly likely that I'll find a correlation against at least one of them. (If I flip a coin 10 times; and then do this experiment 1000 times, it's not unlikely that at least one of those 10-times iterations I'll get 10 ten heads). So maybe I find that ketchup consumption is very closely correlated with public transit availability, across cultures and times and governments. That doesn't really mean that ketchup causes public transit or vice versa, it just means that if you have enough data, you're going to find happenstance correlations.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by stevvooe on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @12:50PM (#7628756)
It seems you are trying hard to find something in my statement with which to refute. I was merely pointing out that the GP's conclusions are probably incomplete, given the data we have on lead.

Most of my previous comments were quite non-committal. For instance, the phrase "lead-soil levels seem to have some negative effect" was cherry-picked for your analysis, and given much stronger meaning than intended. First, let's examine the word choice of "seem". It means "give the impression or sensation of being something or having a particular quality." This modifies the statement, to imply that the data "gives the impression" that there is "some negative effect". This is a much weaker statement than a hypothesis on the effect of lead-soil levels on poverty-stricken neighborhood. Perhaps, that statement would have been more clear if written as, "lead-soil levels seem to have an effect on crime". The implication from the sentence that follows is that the value of "some" is "crime".

It very well could be that lack of political power caused lead-producing activities to be concentrated in low-income neighborhoods. However, the issue at hand is not that lead-soil levels cause poverty; it's that lead-soil levels increase the incidence of crime. This point may not have been clear, as conceded above.

Indeed, correlation does not imply causation, but we know much about the health effects of lead [1] and its impact on decision making. We know that the correlation of crime rates with increasing and decreasing lead-levels, in a variety of situations, throughout many policies and governments, holds. We know both a pathway and have a strong correlation. Dismissing this as happenstance is unwise.

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead#Health_effects

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by Lambdanaut on Monday April 21, 2014 @01:42PM (#7622413)
Those seem to absolutely be factors, perhaps the overwhelmingly influential ones, but the question is how influential is this leaded gas business. Where does it fit into the big picture?
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by splitrocket on Monday April 21, 2014 @12:51PM (#7622016)
All of those factors have increased in the past twenty years and yet crime continues to fall. Your explanatory paradigm needs reworking.
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by njharman on Monday April 21, 2014 @12:08PM (#7621757)
Yeah I'm pretty sure I'm gonna give more credence to scientific studies than Timmmmmm's opinion on what is obviouis.
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by jrochkind1 on Monday April 21, 2014 @01:04PM (#7622135)
This reminds me very much of the study that correlated legalized abortion with a decline in crime -- I believe it also showed it wasn't just a general global trend with legalized abortion and dropping crime, but that places that legalized abortion first saw crime drop first etc.

I think the conclusion is obvious: Removing lead from petrol lead to legalized abortion. Or was it vice versa?

But seriously, I think we need statistical analysis showing the correlation between legalized abortion and unleaded gasoline. Perhaps it would actually show that places that legalized abortion first actually WERE correlated with places that unleaded gasoline first.

It would be silly to assume causation there, even if the correlation were just as strong. Which would be a useful reminder about correlation and causation. Just because you have a correlation where causation is _plausible_ still doesn't mean causation.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by achy on Monday April 21, 2014 @08:08AM (#7620695)
It's always interesting when statistics correlate across multiple frames (time, location, etc.); however that still doesn't prove causality. I'm inclined to think that the causes behind an area being slow to remove leaded gasoline could also affect crime rates.
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by edmccard on Monday April 21, 2014 @08:24AM (#7620735)
>I'm inclined to think that the causes behind an area being slow to remove leaded gasoline could also affect crime rates.

The statistics show a 20-year lag between the banning of leaded gasoline and reduction in crime rates. So even if "unwilling to ban leaded gas" and "high crime 20 years later" could be correlated, it seems less likely that the same things that cause "willing to ban leaded gas" are also the cause of "lower crime 20 years later".

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by originofspecie on Monday April 21, 2014 @12:44PM (#7621986)
That's not entirely true. One factor could be that less progressive urban areas are both less willing to remove lead from gasoline and less willing to fund community outreach programs. Community out reach programs may take years to gain traction and become effective. Banning gasoline is witnessed in a much shorter time frame. This would explain the lag between crime rate drops and banning of leaded gasoline.
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by VLM on Monday April 21, 2014 @12:35PM (#7621931)
Its interesting to model the biosphere hydraulically.

So lead from leaded gas drips into the barrel representing the local ecology, and the lead contaminant drips out of the biosphere at a rate that obviously must depend on local climate. Presumably lead contaminant flows into the oceans or gets buried in the ground at a rate dependent on local weather.

Yet the stats show a nearly perfect and consistent shift 20 years after the addition of lead to the environment stops. That's just biologically weird, like a part of brain development doesn't depend on local lead levels, but on the first derivative of lead levels or something.

It COULD make sense if lead only causes problems when inhaled. Not consumed in food, not drinking water, purely and exclusively inhaled. Even then, local dust storms and the like should totally mess with the supposed global 20 year effect latency.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by Terr_ on Monday April 21, 2014 @08:22PM (#7624937)
Lead reacts with other elements! If it was as un-reactive as gold, it probably wouldn't be as toxic.

Just for starters, burning leaded gasoline can involve pure Lead, Lead(II) oxide, Lead(II) bromide, and Lead(II) chloride.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetraethyllead#Reactions

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by edmccard on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @02:54PM (#7629595)
>It COULD make sense if lead only causes problems when inhaled

I think inhalation of engine exhaust is the main "delivery method" for lead pollution from leaded gasoline.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by charlieflowers on Monday April 21, 2014 @02:57AM (#7620101)
Perhaps another study should be done following individuals. It seems a decent attempt at disproving the hypothesis.

Take say 50 specific individuals ... actually look at where they lived each year of their lives, and estimate as accurately as possible their lead exposure. If they move cross country, "follow" them and estimate the change in lead exposure accordingly.

Once you have an assessment of the lifetime lead exposure of the 50 people, see if it predicts their levels of criminal behavior or aggression.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by gwern on Monday April 21, 2014 @12:52PM (#7622035)
Crime is rare enough that you wouldn't get any sort of conclusive result from the variations in lead level among 50 people.

(Example: suppose 0.1% of people become murders in their lives, and lead is 100% responsible for every murder, and you had 2 groups of 50 people who had either tons of lead or no lead exposure at all; what will the result be? Likely, no murderers in your total group of 100 at all and certainly no difference between the two groups - despite extremely generous assumptions!)

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by bjeanes on Monday April 21, 2014 @11:27AM (#7621516)
I'm not sure that would work. The 20 odd year lag seems to be a generational gap, not a delay in concrete effects on any specific person.
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by dragonwriter on Monday April 21, 2014 @01:14PM (#7622214)
What they might also be misssing -- and the article highlights this -- is that its not just a correlation analysis. There's also a fairly well-developed explanation for the causal mechanism that justifies the hypothesis -- lead has already been established to have significant effects on brain development and behavior (and been specifically linked problems in impulse control and executive functioning.)
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by Flow on Monday April 21, 2014 @05:35AM (#7620395)
Thank you for this really interesting comment.

I wonder if the lead could leave the body, and if the effects it had are somewhat reversed over time, for those that lived in environments with much traffic.

Do you have any idea about this?

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by ekr on Monday April 21, 2014 @05:53AM (#7620429)
If I remember correctly (haven't read this article), there's some sort of offset between decrease in lead and crime reduction, which seems to suggest that it is infants and young children who are affected, or lead actually affects the development of some areas of the brain (the offset was explained by the fact that infants and children don't usually commit crimes, but they do once they get slightly older).

So it is not lead itself, (or the presence of it in your organism) that makes you more likely to commit crimes, but having your brain development impaired by it while an infant that does.

I don't have time to search for the article, but it came up with the last discussion on this topic here.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by duskwuff on Monday April 21, 2014 @01:27PM (#7622299)
My understanding is that lead poisoning during pregnancy and early childhood causes the brain to not develop normally, which is what likely leads to a propensity to criminal behavior. Removing lead from the body later in life would be unlikely to help, as the damage has already occurred.
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by shawkinaw on Monday April 21, 2014 @01:55AM (#7619990)
Not to mention the fact that it makes a lot of sense. Statistics is not the only evidence supporting this theory.
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by mendicantB on Monday April 21, 2014 @05:25AM (#7620377)
Statistics is the means of testing whether or not something is evidence.

I understand what you meant, it's an intuitive conclusion, one that doesn't seem like magic. But, something making sense usually does not correlate with or serve as evidence of it being true.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by Symmetry on Monday April 21, 2014 @10:07AM (#7621090)
something making sense usually does not correlate with or serve as evidence of it being true.

It's true that statistics is required to be sure if something is true, but it's a priori far more likely that a rise in violent crime is caused by a substance known to damage people's brains than by, say, the gravitational influence of Pluto. And we rightly demand careful confirmation when someone finds a particle traveling at a velocity greater than c than when it is found to be traveling at a velocity less than c.

EDIT: And more to the point, I hope you don't find the hypothesis that violence in the 70s caused leaded gasoline in the 50s as that leaded gasoline in the 50s caused violence in the 70s, and that you would agree that one of those two hypothesis needs more evidence before we accept it. Granted, it could easily be some more complicated net of causality, but just between those two.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by mendicantB on Monday April 21, 2014 @05:50PM (#7624185)
I didn't wish to bring in Bayesian approaches here so as to keep it simple. You are correct in your assertion about likeliness given a priori intuition, and I agree with the linking.

But, there is a stark contrast between leveraging prior information to strengthen your estimates and stating that prior information serves as evidence or correlates with outcomes, which was my original assertion.

Either way, I'm a big fan of leveraging common sense (viz Bayesian approaches) so I can't disagree.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by Symmetry on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @11:05AM (#7628071)
If prior information didn't correlate with outcomes then it would provide no value and shouldn't be used.
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by DennisP on Monday April 21, 2014 @09:55AM (#7621034)
If you take a bayesian approach it affects your prior.
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by abandonliberty on Monday April 21, 2014 @11:42AM (#7621601)
The answer to any headline question is supposed to be 'No!'

Thank you.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by FranOntanaya on Monday April 21, 2014 @04:27AM (#7620270)
Aren't the politics required to enforce lead reduction the same that would tackle crime, though? I don't think there are many enviromentally-friendly corrupt parties.
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by jtheory on Monday April 21, 2014 @06:43AM (#7620521)
The crime reduction reliably occurs 20 (23, from the graph?) years after the lead reduction; there's no response in the crime rate until the less-lead-exposed babies have become adults.

The politicians who tackled crime (or didn't, or did whatever) 20 years ago haven't been in power most of the time since then, generally.

I've read about this theory before; it's impressive and (to me, at least) pretty persuasive.

Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by originofspecie on Monday April 21, 2014 @12:47PM (#7621998)
To paraphrase a comment I made further up, banning lead in gasoline is a binary initiative that doesn't take a long time to initiate. Cracking down on crime is a longer process.
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by wisty on Monday April 21, 2014 @04:53AM (#7620325)
You wouldn't think there were many corrupt religious parties either, but politics doesn't always work that way.
Re:Did removing lead from petrol spark a decline in crime? by lmm on Monday April 21, 2014 @04:31AM (#7620279)
Huhwhat? What's corruption got to do with it?