News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Capital Man: Thomas Piketty is economics’ biggest sensati... by WalterBright on Sunday April 20, 2014 @11:02PM (#7619547)
> He's pointed out that capitalism is flawed -- that inequality is not an unintended result, but rather an inherent feature of it.

Of course it's an inherent feature of it. If, by some mechanism, every one was economically equal, what would be the point of anyone bothering to try to do anything?

Re:Capital Man: Thomas Piketty is economics’ biggest sensati... by belorn on Sunday April 20, 2014 @11:31PM (#7619628)
Read simonster comment, posted 20m before yours.

If wealth becomes a hereditary entitlement rather than an incentive for hard work, then no matter how much you work you can never become economically equal.

If you can not earn wealth by working, what is then the point of work?

Re:Capital Man: Thomas Piketty is economics’ biggest sensati... by joeclark77 on Monday April 21, 2014 @03:09AM (#7620127)
Why do you have to "become economically equal" in order for wealth to be an incentive for work? Can no one "earn wealth by working" except in reference to Bill Gates or Paris Hilton or someone? Is wealth defined only in terms of "who I'm ahead of"? If I go from rags to riches, is it meaningless because in the same time Bill Gates went from one mansion to another mansion?
Re:Capital Man: Thomas Piketty is economics’ biggest sensati... by belorn on Monday April 21, 2014 @05:22AM (#7620370)
It all depend. Slaves sometimes competed with each other in order to get favors from the slave owner. In reference to the slave owner, they could never earn enough to be free but if they might work hard enough to get food for the day, so was it meaningless to work hard?

Ever heard the song sixteen ton? How meaningful is the work in such situation?

Re:Capital Man: Thomas Piketty is economics’ biggest sensati... by vanderZwan on Sunday April 20, 2014 @11:06PM (#7619557)
I know that this concept it pretty ingrained in American culture, but there's like... decades of psychological research on the topic of motivation debunking it - not even people who believe this principle act according to it.

I don't believe for one second that your prime motivation do make D was economical, for example.

Re:Capital Man: Thomas Piketty is economics’ biggest sensati... by WalterBright on Monday April 21, 2014 @02:45AM (#7620080)
Most people don't particularly like their jobs. Do you think people like cleaning carpets for a living, for example? How about the guy spending time away from his family, driving a truck?
Re:Capital Man: Thomas Piketty is economics’ biggest sensati... by vanderZwan on Monday April 21, 2014 @06:50AM (#7620534)
(just to be absolutely clear here: I'm not saying everyone should be economically perfectly equal)

By that logic, cleaning carpets and truck driving should be among the highest paying jobs in the US, but I doubt that one would get a straight line if one were to plot "how much people hate their job" vs income.

Also, it's probably a good rule of thumb to ask yourself with any economic theory of the last century that is of Western origin: "how much did the political pressure to prove the Soviets wrong at all costs influence this line of thinking, or the adoption of it?" I think it applies here.

I am not saying carrots and sticks have no influence whatsoever, just that thinking it explains everything is extremely simplistic. Even if they did work universally, there are more types of carrots and sticks than just economical ones, and they are often conflicting. Then there are types of motivation that are different altogether. For example: there is clear evidence that rewards can be counterproductive to motivation in certain situations because they undermine intrinsic motivation (which works differently). Just look up the psychological research cited by critics of gamification, for example.

Anyway, this topic is way to big for a HN comment, but what I'm trying to say is that there's much more to motivation. By and large, the evidence suggests that once a lack of money as an impediment to "personal freedom" (I'm oversimplifying here) is off the table, people are motivated by different reasons. Social reasons, moral reasons, hedonistic reasons, you name it.