However, I don't read Piketty as saying that inequality itself is unsustainable. Rather, inequality tends to undermine democracy. Thus, "unsustainable" here should be read to mean "unsustainable in conjunction with our commonly held egalitarian, democratic values."
> We humans are really bad at designing institutions that outlast the life expectancy of a single human being. The average democratically elected administration lasts 3-8 years; public corporations last 30 years; the Leninist project lasted 70 years (and went off the rails after a decade). The Catholic Church, the Japanese monarchy, and a few other institutions have lasted more than a millennium, but they're all almost unrecognizably different.
> So. You, and a quarter of a million other folks, have embarked on a 1000-year voyage aboard a hollowed-out asteroid. What sort of governance and society do you think would be most comfortable, not to mention likely to survive the trip without civil war, famine, and reigns of terror?
It's totally disingenuous to make claims as if there was some kind of "true" and eternal Rome.
The Roman Empire spent a heck of a lot of money and effort on their people though. Don't forget that in those times you could give a f*ck less about being royalty. If you were in the protected zones of the Romans you were already winning.
To Romans living inside the protected lands, the 'outside world' looked cold, harsh, and barbaric. So, you could put up with inequality as long as those aristocrats were making sure that there were roads, aquifers, and soldiers! :P
Also, slaves could eventually attain freedom and citizenship. So, while it was not a good life it still had potential to become a decent one.
Now, there were uprisings against the Romans by people who benefited from years of Roman protection and decided later on 'to plot their own course'. But that story is old/new. Happened to the Brits, Persians, Mongolians, etc.
The Romans spent centuries withholding the northern tribes of Europe, like Picts and Teutonic peoples, the barbarians from the gate. But after adjustments to modern propagation speeds, the northern wars were much like a flash revolution in Egypt I would suggest.
The USA didn't change much due to the revolution. The US Civil War was a much greater inequality-related upheaval
He is arguing that the inequality capitalism generates is unsustainable.
(2) It is most certainly not what Piketty means by capitalism ... which is what we are discussing here.
Whatever else you might say about inequality, "unsustainable" is an obvious falsehood.
Roman civilization, for example, lasted two thousand years. Eight times as long as the United States. Think about that. One hundred generations of men lived and died as Romans. And the Roman Empire featured radical inequality, of the sort that we could never have in modern America, no matter what the Gini coefficient was.
On one side was the Emperor and his soldiers, who could have you and your entire family tortured to death, purely on a whim (see Caligula). On the other side were slaves, who had no human rights at all and were treated as property. And between them, countless peasants starved to death every time there was a bad harvest, while countless aristocrats taxed their lands to fund lavish banquets. (In the Roman tax system, tax collection was outsourced; the tax collector was responsible for finding a certain amount, and anything above that he could keep for himself.)
That's some serious fucking inequality right there. And I'm certainly not saying it's a good idea, or that we should try to emulate them. But it was, as a raw historical fact, extremely sustainable, lasting eight times as long as the US has so far.