News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check by amirmc on Sunday April 20, 2014 @07:31AM (#7616488)
If we don't start building (and pushing for) more distributed/decentralised systems then this is the future we can expect more of. Aside from this, why should my TV need to dial home at all?
Re:Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check by sjtrny on Sunday April 20, 2014 @07:45AM (#7616513)
Why? To confirm connectivity.

Welcome to HN, where answering a question gets downvoted.

Re:Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check by amirmc on Sunday April 20, 2014 @07:48AM (#7616521)
My browser doesn't do that so there's really no need for a TV to do that.
Re:Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check by andybak on Sunday April 20, 2014 @07:56AM (#7616537)
Are you sure your browser doesn't do that? There's usually some code that checks for 'captive portals' - i.e. wifi providers that want you to login before giving you a real internet connection.
Re:Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check by amirmc on Sunday April 20, 2014 @08:13AM (#7616565)
What I mean is that my browser (Safari) doesn't dial home (Apple) to decide whether or not it can try serving me content (HackerNews). NB That doesn't mean it never connects to Apple without my knowledge (or elsewhere), but rather that it's not a point of failure.

Edit: I'm making a distinction between what my browser does vs the OS and wifi. In any case, your home TV doesn't really have to deal with captive portals.

Re:Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check by nwh on Sunday April 20, 2014 @08:18AM (#7616572)
Your Mac does exactly that actually.

http://blog.erratasec.com/2010/09/apples-secret-wispr-reques...

Apple broke the page once and everybody's wifi broke in response. Single point of failure.

Re:Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check by tjoff on Sunday April 20, 2014 @08:52AM (#7616628)
How did everybody's wifi broke? I would have imagined that the only thing that would have happened was that, for wifis that required a login portal, you would have to launch your browser manually and let the portal hijack any pagerequest.

How did they manage to ensure that this didn't work if there wasn't such a portal or if you did it manually?

Re:Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check by ninkendo on Sunday April 20, 2014 @10:45AM (#7616904)
It's not safari that does it but the "OS" itself, and by that I mean the wireless networking tool. I would imagine that there's some code that runs upon successful connection to an AP and checks to see if you're in a captive portal or not.

The resulting UI looks like a plain window with no UI elements except a close button and a browser frame so you can auth with the captive portal system, and goes away once connectivity is "restored".

Re:Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check by amirmc on Sunday April 20, 2014 @08:44AM (#7616619)
Thanks for the info. That page talks about iOS but is the same true of OSX?
Re:Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check by ubernostrum on Sunday April 20, 2014 @09:39AM (#7616745)
Something like that, most likely -- OS X also detects when a network captures and redirects requests until you log in/agree to terms/whatever, and pops a special window for you to do that in as soon as it connects to such a network.
Re:Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check by uuid_to_string on Sunday April 20, 2014 @10:14AM (#7616814)
How did you reach this conclusion?

At least with devices running iOS, if you let the charge drop to zero, and it loses its cached network settings, and then when you try to reconnect to your home wifi router, it will look for a file called

library/test/success.html at www.apple.com

which contains one line: Success.

If that file is missing, you will not be allowed to connect to your own home LAN, because Apple thinks you are behind a "captive portal". I redirect *.apple.com to stop iAd, ntp and other Apple crap even when I'm connected to the internet, so unlike the OP, this is a problem even when www.apple.com is not down for maintenance.

One solution is to redirect www.apple.com to your own httpd serving a local copy of /library/test/success.html.

In short, you are wrong. Redirect apple.com comains to your own httpd and read your logs.

There is lots of dialing home coming from iOS and indeed some of it will affect your ability to read content.

Re:Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check by Piskvorrr on Sunday April 20, 2014 @09:05AM (#7616663)
However, if that check fails, you'll only get a _notification_ "probably captive portal, you may want to login at yada yada" - instead of "Apple is down, no connectivity for you, nyah nyah".

Annoying, but not a showstopper.

Re:Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check by sjtrny on Sunday April 20, 2014 @09:08AM (#7616667)
You asked why so I answered. I didn't state a position about whether it should be doing it or not.
Re:Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check by gpvos on Sunday April 20, 2014 @10:05AM (#7616793)
There are better ways to check connectivity. At least let it check multiple sites instead of only samsung.com .

Also, the answer is wrong. It does not just check connectivity, but downloads an XML file containing information on services that it is supposed to show.

Re:Spoofing the Samsung Smart TV Internet Check by conroe64 on Monday April 21, 2014 @06:10AM (#7620460)
You have to act more appalled by trivial annoyances, or you slow down the building of the whole hyperbole storm that the people here like to create. Otherwise, they are unable to distract themselves from the boredom and feelings of lack of empowerment in their lives.