Re:How Can I Invest in Microfinance? Part 2: My Zidisha Expe...
by BobbyH on Friday April 18, 2014 @09:23PM
(#7612164)
I take your point. It's just that if those four loans default, you will be down 16%. If that happens, you will lose your principal and also not earn interest on those defaulted loans. So even though you charged an 8.4% APR, you will only earn interest on 84% of your loan balance. So unless a miracle happens, it doesn't seem likely that you will break even.
Here are some details on those four loans:
* Alex made one late partial payment ($1.17) on his $100 loan and is 108 days late on his second payment: https://www.zidisha.org/microfinance/loan/Macbul/3583.html
* Margret hasn't "rescheduled" her loan even though she hasn't made a payment for four months: https://www.zidisha.org/microfinance/loan/margret-muthoni/34...
* Cynthia missed her first four payments, rescheduled her loan, and is now two months behind: https://www.zidisha.org/microfinance/loan/cynthia1988/3090.h...
* Soknya missed three months of payments, rescheduled, and is now 67 days late: https://www.zidisha.org/microfinance/loan/sdndiaye/1908.html
However, are you considering the gross interest income I will earn on the loans that don't default over the forthcoming period? This will partially offset some of the defaults, I can't say with precision to what extent. I count only principal outstanding, not interest income due. So, to some extent this will lessen the impact of possible defaults.
Finally, I have done a couple of new bids since my cut-off date of April 6th when I downloaded the data, so the numbers might not add up 100%. Oh, and Jessica is my wife, she started on Zidisha first, before I took over!
At the end of the day I am hesistant to say resolutely that Zidisha is a break-even venture. It has been so far, but subject to certain assumptions which I hope I have stated clearly. 18 months is a decent trial-period, but it's not a perfect analysis. And if I do subsequently lose a few percent on $1000 that is tolerable. Would I put $10.000 on the platform? No. And comments warning that Zidisha needs to tighten delinquency are completely accurate, and to an extent I am gambling on their ability to do just that - progress seems good so far (in 2014). What intrigues me is the innovation in the business model. It is disruptive. It is a first-mover in this space. Does that mean the model is perfectly refined and cannot be improved? I doubt it, and I look forward to seeing how they develop. But I think it is worth giving them a chance, which is what I have done (to a modest extent), and waiting to see what happens. I will update my blog periodically when more data comes in.