A team has a capacity for arguments that depletes over time as arguments exhaust the team members. Arguments happening in rapid succession set up a vicious cycle, because there's a migraine aura of bad communications surrounding any big argument, and difficult decisions that happen in that aura spark needless new arguments. Lots of arguments also carry a potential for resentment, which creates a longer-term communication problem which sometimes insidiously builds as the company runs.
The "trial arguments" theory that Quora comment suggests seems to me a little like those parents who throw "chicken pox parties". It's probably fine and maybe even pragmatic, but it's a risk.
Why do I say this? Oh, no reason.. I just like typing things in boxes on the Internet!
- Joel confuses "easy" (50/50) with "fair" (working out the right number)
- It is better to argue yourselves to death early, when nobody else is affected, than later, when people are depending on you
- The expected value of an IOU is negligible because investors usually force you to waive them as a precondition of investing and they go to zero if the company fails
But perhaps I'm wrong. I'm expecting a round of innovation in equity allocation as companies heed sama's advice and try new things. I'm very curious to see how it works out!
There's been a lot of discussion since, including https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2445447 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3489719.
Also, at the time, Dan Shapiro argued against it here: http://www.quora.com/What-do-you-think-about-Joel-Spolskys-a...
I also think the share distribution Wizards of the Coast (Pokemon, Magic the Gathering) accidentally used was interesting: founders had no shares, and worked their way up into the single digits, which supported small, individual investors, but it's probably not recommended if you're planning for traditional investment: http://www.peteradkison.com/blog-entry-2-wizards-of-the-coas... and http://www.peteradkison.com/blog-entry-3-wizards-of-the-coas...