Re:Why can’t America get the sidewalk café right?
by saraid216 on Friday April 18, 2014 @01:53PM
(#7610336)
I haven't finished reading his book, so I can't speak to the context in which he says this.
I guess it depends on what you consider force. If you stop encouraging suburb development, would that be force? It would certainly promote such redistribution, but I wouldn't consider that force. As another HN link noticed, this kind of financial incentive to move into the city has already started happening, but it has been a bottom-up bit.
Re:Why can’t America get the sidewalk café right?
by Turing_Machine on Friday April 18, 2014 @03:39PM
(#7610884)
IMO, removing subsidies wouldn't be force, but raising taxes would.
Reading what I wrote above in the light of day makes it sound like I'm advocating forcible population redistribution. I'm not... just pointing out that a European-style urban environment probably can't happen in the low densities typical of the United States, and that the only way to achieve such densities here would probably require force (which would be a bad thing, IMO).