[deleted]
Re:Lavabit appeal confirms original ruling [pdf]
by tptacek on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @02:32PM
(#7599576)
No, your assertion doesn't follow logically. For instance, during the course of a trial, an antagonistic witness can be treated as hostile, giving examining attorneys more leeway in what questions they get to ask. Or, a dishonest witness can be treated as if all their statements were untrustworthy in jury instructions.
Being punished for hurting a prosecutor's feelings is not the same as being penalized for obstructing the proceedings of a court case.
This decision spends tens of pages applying the law to the facts of the case, and deciding against Levison.
Presumably Twitter's lawyers avoid brinksmanship, knowing that they'll inevitably lose and, in the process, lose credibility with the court.