Re:Network of 75 Million Neurons of the Mouse Brain Mapped f...
by ChuckMcM on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @02:25AM
(#7596391)
I can't say I agree with this "Intelligence is an emergent behavior, and it needs time to work and learn. Since you have to model every single neuron firing at the same time, the speed at which you can run this model is unreasonably slow."
Part of the issue is semantics, what do you consider intelligent? And part is empirical. Insects pop out of a an egg and start doing their 'thing.' Some argue its "intelligence" and others argue is programming of an automaton. Having seen a number of mice go through the whole cycle, from birth to snake chow, my observation was that capabilities developed over time but intelligence appeared to be innate. (which is different than learning, it is in my opinion the ability to learn). I don't know how one my structure an experiment of keeping a mouse effectively in a coma until its body was fully grown, and then measuring its ability to learn, but I did observe that baby mice learned readily things like how to avoid losing track of mom, and how to keep warm. Programming or instinct or something else I don't know.
I do agree that without inputs the brain does not learn but I would not agree that it is not intelligent. So the question might be how fast can it learn. An interesting question might be is it possible to measure the speed of learning independent of a mouse acting on that learning.
Part of the issue is semantics, what do you consider intelligent? And part is empirical. Insects pop out of a an egg and start doing their 'thing.' Some argue its "intelligence" and others argue is programming of an automaton. Having seen a number of mice go through the whole cycle, from birth to snake chow, my observation was that capabilities developed over time but intelligence appeared to be innate. (which is different than learning, it is in my opinion the ability to learn). I don't know how one my structure an experiment of keeping a mouse effectively in a coma until its body was fully grown, and then measuring its ability to learn, but I did observe that baby mice learned readily things like how to avoid losing track of mom, and how to keep warm. Programming or instinct or something else I don't know.
I do agree that without inputs the brain does not learn but I would not agree that it is not intelligent. So the question might be how fast can it learn. An interesting question might be is it possible to measure the speed of learning independent of a mouse acting on that learning.