News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by tptacek on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @08:29PM (#7595214)
They don't teach you that in "MBA class" because it isn't true. Equity allocation and executive authority are mostly orthogonal concerns. Smart teams of equal cofounders manage to pick leaders all the time. Controversial decisions at early-stage companies don't get decided based on equity; by the time the equity card gets played, your company is dead anyways.

Your calculator appears to, among other things, allocate equity based on who paid for business cards.

I don't think anyone's done a better job of explaining how to handle equity than Joel Spolsky. Here's his answer to this question:

https://gist.github.com/isaacsanders/1653078

He even addresses the "paying for business cards" question!

(FWIW: Matasano is an "equal split among founders" company; we elected to make Dave our President and Decider.)

Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by kristianp on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @09:24PM (#7595442)
This sounds good. One point I don't agree with is this one:

    What happens if not all the early employees need to take a salary?

    Don't resolve these problems with shares. Instead, just keep a ledger of how 
    much you paid each of the founders, and if someone goes without salary, give 
    them an IOU. Later, when you have money, you'll pay them back in cash.
Those who don't take a salary don't take any risk, so I would say the IOU should be greater than the missed salary as a minimum.
Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by tptacek on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @10:02PM (#7595604)
So pay it back with interest. The point is to avoid forcing the valuation question into internal tactical decisions, which is what you're doing if you issue shares to offset deferred salary.
Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by alain94040 on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @09:35PM (#7595485)
Your calculator appears to, among other things, allocate equity based on who paid for business cards.

Respectfully, appearances can be deceiving. Without giving away the secret sauce, it's fair to say that most of the questions in the calculator are not measuring what they seem to be asking for. To get to the truth of a situation, indirect questions often work better. I'll ask you to trust me a little bit.

Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by tptacek on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @09:39PM (#7595501)
I'm not sure "secret sauce" is something people should be looking for in founder equity allocation.