Re: Krueger Statement on Use of Airbnb for Floating Brothels
by a_bonobo on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @07:30PM
(#7594987)
Would this be an example for Tragedy Of The Commons?
A small group of users act rational and in self-interest (by offering prostitution, illegal gambling etc.) and therefore make it worse for the other 'legitimate' users. In the long run, the 'illegal' users destroy AirBnB (by causing stricter laws etc.) and therefore destroy their own business.
Re: Krueger Statement on Use of Airbnb for Floating Brothels
by stormbrew on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @07:34PM
(#7595003)
It is absolutely an informal fallacy[1]. The onus is on the person making the claim of similarity to demonstrate why that similarity is valid, so on its own it lacks any argumentative weight.
Something being an informal fallacy doesn't mean that it can't be a component of a good argument (ie. correlation not implying causation doesn't mean there are no cases where something can be demonstrated to be causitive), it means that it is not an argument in and of itself.
If you believe that AirBnB WILL be used for prostitution, but WILL NOT be used for gambling or a drug operation, you should articulate a reason why you think there is a difference in kind that would prevent people from using AirBnB for those other purposes.